Grounded

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ellery spoke first, and he spoke as what he was — a man who had spent thirty years in airline finance before coming to the lessor's side of the table, who knew to the decimal what seventy-four aircraft meant. It meant, he said, roughly a third of the company's revenue, concentrated in a single counterparty whose entire operation would stop on Thursday morning like a heart. It meant the credit facility's covenants being re-read by bankers over the weekend. It meant the other ten clients — every one of them — telephoning their own counsel to ask whether Banks Aerolease had just become a lessor who grounded first and reviewed afterwards, and whether their own leases, negotiated in better weather, contained the same sentence in the same place. It meant, he said, choosing his words with distaste, that by Friday morning the story in every newsroom in the country would no longer be about a security contractor's hands on a passenger. It would be about a billionaire who had been embarrassed on an airplane and had reached, within one business day, for the largest weapon in his building. They would call it extortion. They would call it a tantrum with a legal department. And the terrible thing, Ellery said, looking directly at Theo, was that the people calling it that would not all be wrong about the *optics* — his mouth twisted on the word — because the optics were indistinguishable from revenge, and the company would wear that resemblance for years.

Whitaker, the governance lawyer, made the colder argument, and made it well. The clause, she said, was drafted — whatever its inspiration — in the language of safety. Safety had a meaning in aviation law, built up over decades of case law about airworthiness and operational control, and a court would strain to give *safe and lawful carriage* its conventional meaning before it gave it Grace Banks's. Two settled complaints, neither adjudicated, both contracted away into silence, and one viral video, did not yet make a demonstrated risk; they made an allegation with excellent footage. If Banks grounded the fleet and Vantage sued — as Vantage would, by Thursday afternoon, with the entire industry watching — Banks might lose, and losing would not merely cost money. Losing would strike the clause itself out of every lease it lived in, and the next chairman, facing the next file, would have nothing. She paused. "Record that I believe the file is exactly what Denise says it is," she said. "Record that I am frightened of spending the one weapon we have on the day we are angriest. That is my whole objection. It is not a small one."

Theo let the silence after her sit for a moment, because she had earned it.

Then he answered, in the same level voice he had used on the telephone all weekend to his bankers and his friends, and it was the voice, though no one in the room said so, of the man in the video — the man who had not shouted in seat 2A either.

"The clause exists," he said, "for exactly the case in which using it is expensive. If it applied only when it cost us nothing, it would not be a clause. It would be a decoration, and Grace did not put decorations in leases. She put it there because she understood that the day it was needed would be a day on which everyone in the room could think of excellent commercial reasons to leave it in the drawer. We are having that day. You are making her argument for her."

He turned a page of the file, though he did not need to.

"I am not grounding this fleet because of what was done to me on Friday. I want that understood in the minutes, because it happens to be true. I have been handled roughly by experts and by amateurs, in boardrooms and in bars, for fifty-nine years, and I have a thicker skin than this company's share price. If Friday were all there was — one contractor, one bad hour, one video — I would have taken Vantage's apology on Saturday, and their settlement, and I would have donated it to something and forgotten the whole business by Christmas. Thinner evidence than this file would not move me. But I am not the file. *This* is the file. A surgeon in a jet bridge, writing like a gentleman about his own humiliation, and being bought a voucher for it. A professor in a side room, asking what law was applied to him, and being sent the terms and conditions. A vice president of that company writing four

News in the same category

Grounded

45 Part