Grounded

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

said, in its statement, that a passenger had been removed for noncompliance. Nothing in that sentence is true except the removal. I have not asked you for a sum, Daniel. I have asked you to say what happened, to whom it happened, and why it was wrong. If that sentence cannot survive your lawyers, then we do not have a settlement. We have a schedule for my fleet to sit on your ramps until your board finds a man who can say it."

It was, Denise thought, the only moment in four days when Theo sounded like what the newspapers had begun to call him. Roarke looked at the folder for a long moment. Then he took it off the table and gave it to his communications chief — not in rebuke; in retirement, the way one hands off a tool that has failed — and said, "I'll write it myself." The chief, to his credit, nodded as if he had expected nothing else, and the session broke for lunch with the shape of the ending visible for the first time to everyone in the room.

That afternoon they did the personnel clauses, and it was here that Theo surprised the table — surprised, if the truth were told, his own side as much as Roarke's. Harker was gone already, his resignation accepted, his pension a matter for lawyers Theo would not join. Doyle's dismissal was agreed in a single exchange, without pleasure on either side: the man had given the order, and the order was the company speaking, and the company could not keep the voice it had spoken in. Then Roarke's people, reading the weather, offered the third name — the officer who had put his hands on Theo and walked him up the aisle between the seatbacks. Officer Dale Renner. There was a draft statement in readiness. His termination could be announced with the settlement. It would, the communications chief said, demonstrate seriousness.

"No," Theo said.

He explained himself without heat, because heat on this point would have cheapened it. Renner would be removed from passenger-facing duties that week; he would be retrained under the new standards or released, at the airline's judgment, through its own due process; and his name would not appear in any announcement of Vantage Air or of Banks Aerolease. "The man used his hands," Theo said. "The system handed him the airplane. It trained him for eleven days, it paid him by the hour through a contractor so that no one at this table had to call him theirs, it buried the first two complaints so that no one had to tell him to stop, and it put him at my row with an order from a manager who never left his office. You may not purchase your absolution with his livelihood, Daniel, and I will not let my name be used to do it. He is owed the process your passengers weren't. That is rather the whole of my argument."

Denise, drafting that evening, wrote the protection clause last and wrote it carefully — the seventh item, shielding any employee who reported a removal or testified truthfully about one from retaliation in scheduling, discipline, or discharge — and in the clause's drafting history, where the lawyers recorded how a provision had come to be, she entered the name the text itself was too general to carry: Shah, P., officer, whose statement of November 19 had been the first true document in the entire affair.

"Will she ever see it?" Theo asked, when Denise showed him the page that evening, in the emptied conference room with the city coming on below like a second, slower circuit board. "The drafting history. Will she know her name is in it?"

"Probably not," Denise said. "It isn't written for her to see. It's written so that in ten years, when some lawyer for some airline argues that the protection clause was boilerplate, a judge can read how it got there. Clauses outlive the people who need them, Theo. That's the argument for writing them down."

Theo nodded, slowly, and Denise watched him decide whether to say the thing he had been deciding whether to say since Monday. "The two complaints," he said at last. "The buried ones. When the reporting starts — the quarterly numbers — those two people will read that their letters are in a count now. A count, Denise. Not an answer. I couldn't get them an answer."

"No," she said. "You couldn't. Their answer was due the week Harker filed them, and the week is three years gone." She closed the folder. "What you got them is the last of it. There won't be a third letter in that file. That's what a standard is — it isn't justice for the people it came too late for. It's a fence built where the cliff already took somebody. You build it anyway."

"Yes," Theo said. "You build it anyway." He was quiet a moment. "When this is signed, I want the young woman — Shah — I want nothing done for her that looks like gratitude from me. A reward from the man she told the truth about would be its own kind of pressure on the next one. The clause is the gratitude. Make sure it stays that way."

News in the same category

Grounded

45 Part