He had worn them the night he disappeared.
She had been eight years old. She still remembered the smell of rain on his wool sleeve, the rough feel of his thumb wiping a tear from her cheek, and the sound of his voice promising he would be back before dawn. Then he had mounted his stallion and ridden away beneath a black, storm-filled sky.
The next morning, his horse was found wandering three miles south by the roaring waters of Big Muddy River, its saddle soaked in dark blood. His body had never been found.
Clara spun around toward the street, her eyes searching the crowd in a sudden frenzy, but the stranger had been swallowed completely by the town.
Behind her, the bronze bell of St. Judeâs Church rang five times, its deep tones rolling across the roofs of Red Creek. Clara stood frozen beside her empty stall, her fingers locked around the silver ghost in her hand.
âYou look as if youâve seen a ghost,â a voice spoke near her shoulder.
Clara jumped, swinging around so fast her skirt whipped against the table legs.
Sheriff Amos Rusk stood beside the counter. He was a broad-bellied man with silver hair tucked beneath a wide-brimmed felt hat, his dark wool vest unbuttoned over a clean white shirt. One heavy, calloused hand rested lightly on his belt, just above his holstered revolver. He had served Red Creek for nearly thirty years, his face a map of sun-wrinkles and old scars. To most people in town, he was dependable, steady, and fatherly.
To Clara, he was the man who had pulled her off the porch steps twenty years ago, fed her hot broth, and raised her when her father failed to return.
âAmos,â Clara gasped, dropping her hand to her side and shoving the silver button deep into her apron pocket. She pulled her fingers out quickly, smoothing the linen as if trying to hide a stolen secret.
Amos smiled, though his grey eyes remained sharp as they swept over her empty counter and settled on the thick bundle of paper money resting beside her tin plates. His thick eyebrows pulled together into a tight ridge.
âBusiness was good today,â Amos said, stepping closer. He reached out with two thick fingers and nudged the top bill. âOr did a bank robber decide he had a sudden craving for blackberry?â
âA man bought all six,â Clara said, her voice sounding thinner than she wanted. âJust a few minutes ago.â
âDid he now?â Amos looked up the street, his eyes tracking the movement of horses and pedestrians near the saloon. âWhat did he look like?â
âTall. Brown coat. Black hat.â Clara hesitated, her thumb pressing against the outside of her pocket where the button rested against her hip. âHe had a scar over his eyebrow.â
Amos went still. It was a subtle changeâjust a stiffening of his jaw and a tightening of his right shoulderâbut Clara had lived with the man long enough to know what it meant. His hand moved an inch closer to his gun stock.
âWhich way did he go?â Amos asked, his voice losing its warm, fatherly tone and taking on the flat, dangerous weight of a lawman.
âEast,â Clara said, pointing down the wooden boardwalk. âToward the timber yards. Amos, who is he? Why would someone give me this much money for six pies?â
Amos turned back to her, forcing a chuckling laugh that sounded hollow even to him. He patted her arm with his heavy hand. âTownâs full of drifters these days, Clara. Gold strikes up in the Black Hills have brought all sorts through Red Creekâfools with more cash than sense. Some cowboy likely had a lucky night at the tables in Green River and wanted to act like a king.â
He picked up the bundle of money and handed it to her. âTake it to the bank before Mr. Vance locks the vault for the evening. Pay your rent. Buy yourself a new pair of boots. Youâve been wearing those cracked ones since last winter.â
Clara took the money, but she didnât move. She stared into Amosâs face, searching the lines around his mouth. âHe left something else, Amos.â
Amos tilted his head. âDid he?â
Clara reached into her apron pocket. For a second, she wanted to pull the silver button out, place it in Amosâs palm, and ask him why a stranger would carry her fatherâs mark into Red Creek twenty years after Silas Whitmore died.
But something held her hand back. A sudden, cold instinct warned her to keep her pocket shut. It was an absurd thoughtâAmos had given her a roof when she had nothing; he had taught her to read, bought her first baking tin, and stood by her fatherâs empty grave when the preacher said the final words. Yet, looking at the tightness around the sheriffâs eyes, Clara felt a chill that had nothing to do with the evening wind.
âHe left his sack,â Clara lied smoothly, pointing to an empty twine string lying on the bench. âLeft before I could give him his change.â
Amos relaxed, his shoulders dropping. âKeep it. If a man throws away a hundred dollars for a piece of pastry, he isnât coming back for his three dollars change.â He patted her shoulder again, harder this time. âLock up your stall, child. Walk home with me. Marthaâs got a pot of beef stew on the stove.â
âI have to clean the tins first,â Clara said, forcing a small smile. âGo on ahead. Iâll be along soon.â
Amos watched her for three long seconds, his gaze heavy and assessing. âDonât stay out past dark, Clara. The windâs turning cold, and this town isn't as quiet as it used to be.â