âI wonât.â
She watched the sheriff walk away, his heavy boots thumping against the boardwalk, his silver hair catching the last rays of the sun. As soon as he turned the corner onto Main Street, Clara pulled her hand from her pocket, opened her palm, and stared at the silver button.
The lightning bolt seemed to glint in the twilight.
She packed her empty tins into her crate, tied her apron string around her waist, and left her stall behind. Instead of heading toward the bank or the sheriffâs house on the hill, Clara turned down the narrow alley between the dry-goods store and the leather tanner.
Red Creek had been built thirty years ago during the timber rush, a rough grid of pine buildings sitting in a valley surrounded by towering, dark mountains. The upper streets were clean, housing the bank, the hotel, and the neat painted homes of the merchants. But down near the riverâwhere the old sawmills sat rotting in the mudâlay the Flats.
It was a place of broken fences, leaning shacks, and narrow dirt tracks where the law rarely walked. It was also where her father had kept his blacksmith forge before he disappeared.
Clara walked fast, her skirt trailing in the dust, her hand buried in her pocket. The sun dropped behind the western peaks, throwing the valley into deep, blue shadows. Lanterns began to flicker in the saloon windows behind her, sending distant sounds of fiddle music and laughter floating through the cold air.
She reached the edge of the Flats and stopped in front of a low, stone structure sitting twenty yards from the riverbank. The roof had fallen in years ago, replaced by a sagging sheet of rusted iron. The wooden doors were missing, their iron hinges red with rust. Weeds grew wild through the cracked dirt floor inside.
This was Silas Whitmoreâs forge.
Clara stepped through the empty doorway. The air inside smelled of damp earth, old ash, and wet stone. She stood in the center of the dark room, looking at the crumbling stone hearth where her father had spent his days pounding red-hot iron into horseshoe nails and wheel rims.
She reached out, touching the cold stone of the anvil bench.
âYou shouldn't have come here alone,â a voice said from the shadow behind the forge.
Clara didn't scream, but her body went stiff. She whirled around, her heel catching on a loose stone, her back slamming against the cold chimney wall.
The stranger stepped out from the dark corner where the roof met the wall. In the dim grey twilight filling the doorway, his tall frame looked even broader than it had on the street. He had taken off his hat, revealing dark hair mixed with silver at the temples.
âWho are you?â Clara demanded, her hand clutching her pocket. âWhy did you leave this button on my counter?â
The man didn't move toward her. He stayed ten feet away, leaning his shoulder against a timber support post, his eyes fixed on her face with that same unbearable stillness.
âMy name is Jesse Cole,â he said.
âThat means nothing to me.â
âIt shouldn't,â Jesse said softly. âI was fifteen years old when I last stood in this valley. I was smaller then. Hungry. Running from a stepfather who used a mule whip to teach me manners.â
Clara frowned, her mind racing. âWhat does that have to do with my father?â
Jesse reached into his coat. Clara flinched, but he pulled out a small, leather-bound notebook, its pages yellowed and frayed at the edges. He held it out toward her.
âYour father found me hiding in the woods behind his charcoal pit,â Jesse said. âI had a broken rib and boots with no soles. He didn't turn me over to the constable. He didn't ask where I came from. He brought me into this forge, gave me a bowl of salt pork, and let me sleep beside the bellows.â
Clara stared at the notebook, then up at his face. âYou worked for him?â
âI was his apprentice for two years,â Jesse said. âHe taught me how to work iron, how to shoe a horse, and how to read an anvil by its ring. He gave me that button when I left for the territories in â61. Said if I ever needed help, I just had to show that silver to a friend, and theyâd know I came from Silas Whitmoreâs shop.â
Clara felt a sharp lump rise in her throat. Her thumb pressed hard against the button in her pocket. âIf you knew him⊠if he was your master⊠why did you come back now? After twenty years?â
Jesse looked away, his eyes drifting to the crumbling stone hearth. âBecause twenty years ago, I was a coward. I ran away when things went dark.â
âWhat do you mean?â Clara took a step forward, her fear forgotten, replaced by a desperate, aching need to know. âThe sheriff said my father was ambushed by river bandits. He said his horse was found covered in blood by the ford.â
Jesse turned his head back to her, his pale blue eyes flashing in the gloom. âAmos Rusk told you that?â
âYes! He raised me! He found his horse!â
A low, bitter laugh escaped Jesseâs lipsâa sound completely devoid of humor. âAmos Rusk didn't find that horse, Clara. He tied it there himself.â
The air seemed to leave the ruined forge. Clara stared at Jesse, her head shaking in violent denial. âNo. Youâre lying. Amos is the sheriff. He was my fatherâs best friend!â
âHe was your fatherâs partner,â Jesse corrected, his voice flat and hard as anvil iron. âBefore Red Creek was a town, when it was just a timber camp, Silas Whitmore and Amos Rusk owned three hundred acres of land along the river. They bought it together for fifty dollars and two rifles.â