He Bought Every Pie Before Sunset. By Dawn, She Learned Why He Had Really Come.

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“He knew,” Clara whispered, her tears finally falling freely, splashing onto the dry parchment. “He knew Amos was coming for him.”

“He knew Amos was greedy,” Jesse said quietly. “Silas was trying to protect the land so the town wouldn't be bought out by mining syndicates. Amos wanted to sell it all to the Denver railroad and make himself a rich man.”

Jesse reached into the iron box and pulled out one of the rolled papers. He unrolled it, showing her a hand-drawn map of the mountains behind Red Creek. A red X was marked at the head of a narrow canyon three miles north.

“The silver seam,” Jesse said. “Amos has been searching for it for twenty years. He knows it exists, but he never found the vein because Silas kept the survey map hidden in this box. That’s why Amos stayed here as sheriff—he couldn't leave until he found the deed and the map.”

Clara looked from the map to the iron box, her heart cold with a sudden, sharp realization.

“The money you gave me today,” she said, looking up at Jesse. “The hundred dollars...”

“It was to get you off the street,” Jesse said softly. “I knew if I bought your pies and gave you the silver button, you’d come looking for answers. But I needed to know if you were still the girl Silas raised—if you had his brave spirit, or if you were under Amos’s thumb.”

“I’m no one’s property,” Clara said, her voice turning hard as glass.

Jesse smiled—a real smile this time, broad and warm, cutting through the shadows of his face. “I know you’re not. You’re Silas Whitmore’s daughter.”

Suddenly, a loud snap broke through the quiet night outside the forge.

Jesse jumped to his feet in a single, fluid movement, his right hand sweeping inside his coat. He pulled out a long-barreled Colt revolver, its blue steel catching the moonlight. He stepped in front of Clara, shielding her with his body.

“Stay down,” he commanded in a harsh whisper.

Outside, the soft thud of horse hooves echoed from the dirt track leading down from Main Street. Three riders pulled up in front of the ruined doorway, their shadows stretching long across the dirt floor.

A lantern was lit, its yellow glare bursting into the dark forge, blinding Clara for a second.

Behind the lantern stood a broad man with silver hair tucked beneath a wide-brimmed felt hat.

Sheriff Amos Rusk.

Amos stepped down from his horse, holding the oil lantern high. Behind him stood two men—rough-looking cowboys in heavy leather vests, both carrying short-barreled shotguns across their saddles.

“I told you not to stay out past dark, Clara,” Amos said. His voice was soft, fatherly, but his eyes were completely cold as they moved from Clara to Jesse, and finally down to the open iron box on the floor.

Clara stood up slowly, stepping out from behind Jesse’s shoulder. She held the parchment deed crushed tight against her hip.

“You lied to me,” Clara said, her voice shaking with a rage she didn't know she possessed. “For twenty years, you sat at my table, ate my bread, and told me you were searching for my father’s killers.”

Amos sighed, a long, tired sound, and rested his hand on his revolver belt. “I didn't lie about searching for them, child. I knew where they were the whole time.”

He looked at Jesse, his eyes narrowing as he studied the scar over the younger man’s eyebrow.

“Jesse Cole,” Amos said smoothly. “I thought you died in a California saloon ten years ago. I should have shot you in the timber loft back in ’64 when I had the chance.”

“You should have,” Jesse agreed, his revolver held steady at Amos’s chest. “It would have saved you a long wait, Sheriff.”

Amos shook his head, looking down at the dirt floor. “Silas was a fool. He was sitting on a mountain of silver and three miles of timber land, and he wanted to leave it for cabbages and horse shoes. The railroad offered us fifty thousand dollars just for the river crossing, Clara. Fifty thousand dollars in gold! We could have built a city here.”

“It wasn't yours to sell!” Clara cried out.

“I made this town!” Amos’s voice snapped like a whip, his fatherly mask slipping completely away to reveal the greedy, bitter man beneath. “I cleared the natives out! I brought the merchants in! I kept the peace for thirty years while your father lay in the dirt! I earned every square foot of this valley!”

He lifted his left hand, gesturing toward the iron box. “Hand over the map and the deed, Clara. Walk away with that bundle of cash Jesse gave you today, and you can catch the morning stage to Denver. You’ll be a rich woman. You can open a hundred bakeries.”

“And if I don't?” Clara asked.

Amos’s face went dark, the shadows from the lantern accentuating the deep lines around his mouth. “Then you’ll join your father in the Big Muddy River. People will say you ran off with a drifter, and no one in Red Creek will ask a single question.”

One of the men behind Amos raised his shotgun, pulling back the heavy twin hammers with two loud, metallic clicks.

Jesse didn't flinch. “Amos,” he said softly. “You’ve got two men with shotguns, but I’ve got six rounds in this Colt, and the first one goes straight between your eyes before those barrels clear their scabbards.”

Amos hesitated, his hand hovering an inch over his holster. He knew Jesse was right—at ten feet, a handgun in trained hands was faster than a long gun drawn from a saddle.

News in the same category

He Bought Every Pie Before Sunset. By Dawn, She Learned Why He Had Really Come.

7 Part