At the top of the road, the lighthouse rose from a shelf of granite. Its tower was white once, but the paint had peeled into long gray scales. The keeper's cottage had lost half its roof. A fence surrounded the grounds, secured by a chain and a padlock.
Mara tried the brass key marked 17. It did not fit.
She walked along the fence, searching for another entrance. Beyond the cottage, a narrow footpath descended toward a line of rocks. At the bottom stood a wooden shed, almost hidden behind scrub pine. The door had a newer padlock, but the hasp was loose enough to move. Someone had opened it recently and failed to close it properly.
Inside were old oil cans, a coil of rope, and a metal cabinet bolted to the floor. On the cabinet was a white label with the number 17.
Mara's key turned.
The cabinet contained a ring of keys, a small first-aid kit, a folded raincoat, and a packet of letters tied with blue thread. The first letter was addressed to Miriam. The second to Jonas. The third had no name, only a date from seven years earlier.
Mara unfolded it.
If the girl comes, tell her the light was never meant for ships. Tell her it was meant to keep a promise. I will meet her when the water is quiet.
There was no signature, but the handwriting matched the note in the parcel. Her father had not written it. The letters were her mother's.
A sound came from outside.
Mara slipped the papers into her bag and turned toward the shed door. A figure stood in the pale light, one hand resting on the frame. She was tall and thin, with dark hair cut short at the jaw and a face that seemed familiar in a way Mara could not place. Her coat was old-fashioned, buttoned high against the cold. She carried no bag.
“You found the cabinet,” the woman said.
“Who are you?”
The woman studied her. “You look more like Elise than Jonas.”
Mara's breath caught. “Miriam?”
“Yes.”
“You're alive.”
“I've been trying to decide whether that's a blessing.”
Mara moved into the doorway. She was close enough to see the fine lines at the corners of the woman's eyes and the small crescent scar above her left eyebrow. She remembered the scar from childhood photographs. She remembered a woman who had once lifted her onto a kitchen counter and let her stir pancake batter. She remembered being told that this woman had died in a car accident in Vermont.
“You're my aunt,” Mara said.
“I'm your mother's sister.”
“Why did everyone tell me you were dead?”
“Because someone had to disappear, and your mother had already been written out of the world. Jonas thought it was safer if you believed the loss was complete.”
“Safer for whom?”
“For you.”
Mara laughed once, without humor. “That's what he wrote in his note. He made me believe my mother was dead for twenty-one years because it was safer. He made me believe you were dead, too.”
“I know.”
“Then you understand why I don't want another explanation that ends with me being grateful.”
Miriam looked down. “I wouldn't ask that of you.”
“Where is my mother?”
“I don't know where she is now.”
Mara's anger sharpened. “You don't know?”
“I haven't seen her in six years. We used to communicate through a lawyer and a dead-drop box in Portland. The box was emptied last spring. After that, nothing.”
“Is she alive?”
“As far as I know.”
The words did not sound like comfort. They sounded like a door left ajar in a house full of smoke.
Mara held up the photograph. “Ruth gave me this. It was taken nine years after the ferry sank.”
Miriam nodded. “We met at Low Tide Beach. Your mother had come back to collect a piece of evidence Jonas had hidden.”
“What evidence?”
“An original dispatch log. Not the copy in the official inquiry. The original.”
“Why does it matter?”
“Because it proves the rescue station received the right distress call. The boat was sent in the wrong direction anyway.”
Mara thought of Owen Pike's father, and of the first recorder file. “Who sent it west?”
“Silas Vane.”
“Did he control the rescue station?”
“Not officially. He controlled the radio maintenance contract and the men who worked the night shift. His company was moving unregistered salvage cargo through the eastern channel. A vessel carrying those containers was not supposed to be in the harbor that night. The Maribel hit a submerged obstruction while the channel was supposed to be clear.”