Corvin stared at the paper. He had never seen it before. He had never abandoned his land. He had lived on it for nineteen years, since Abram died, and Abram had lived on it before him. The well had never been unused. The barn had stood until Rawlins burned it.
It is a forgery, Corvin said, and his voice was flat, because anger, when it is real, does not always shout. "I never signed that. I never left. I never abandoned anything."
It is worse than a forgery, Cole said, and he turned the paper so Brandt could see it. "The signature is yours, Mr. Brandt, or a very good copy of it, and the date is three weeks ago, the same week the fences were cut. The clerk who took it in remembered the man who brought it, because he was in a hurry, and because he smelled of smoke."
Brandt's smile did not quite hold. He reached for the paper, and Cole put his hand over it, gently, but firmly, and did not let him take it.
I am seizing this filing, Cole said. "It will go to the territorial court, with the ledger, with the spur, with the statements from Dr. Alvarez, and with the testimony I have heard today. Mr. Rawlins, you are charged with assault and arson. You will be held in the jailhouse until the court sends for you."
Rawlins stood so fast his chair fell over. "You cannot hold me on the word of a girl and a boy and a rancher who drinks from a well he does not own."
I can, Cole said, "and I am. Take him."
The deputy, a young man named Ellis who had been standing by the door with his hand near his own revolver, stepped forward. Rawlins looked at him, and at Cole, and at the window, as if he were weighing whether to run, and then he saw the street outside, and the people who had gathered there, and the way they were looking at him, and he let Ellis take his arm. He swore as he was led out, but the swearing sounded thin, like a man talking to himself in an empty room.
Brandt remained standing, his coat still smooth, his hands now clasped in front of him, as if he were praying, though Corvin doubted he was.
Mr. Brandt, Cole said, "you are held for questioning. You will not leave Copperton until the court has seen this filing and heard your answers. Your riders will leave town today, or they will be held too."
Brandt looked at Corvin, and his eyes were cold, and his voice, when he spoke, was low enough that only the people nearest him could hear it properly. "You think a ledger and a girl's story will keep that well, Torne? The law is longer than a summer, and the desert is drier than your memory. I will have that water. If not by a filing, then by a claim. If not by a claim, then by a court. You cannot guard a well forever."
Corvin did not answer him. He looked at Aiyana, and she looked back at him, and neither of them spoke, because there was nothing to say to a man who had just been caught with a forged paper in his hand and still believed he would win.
Cole wrote the charges in his book, slowly, in his own careful hand, and when he had finished, he blotted the page, and he looked up, and he said, "This hearing is over. The record stands."
Outside, the sun was high and white, and the street was full of people who had been waiting to see who would come out of the sheriff's office first, and what their faces would tell them. Corvin stepped into the light with the ledger under his arm, and Aiyana stepped beside him, and Sam followed, holding his sling with his good hand, and the town, for the first time in weeks, seemed to breathe.
They did not linger on the steps. Corvin knew the value of leaving a room while the record was still fresh in everyone's mind, before Brandt's friends could begin to reshape it in the saloon. He helped Sam onto his horse, and he helped Aiyana, and he mounted his own horse, and they rode out of Copperton at a walk, not a gallop, because a walk says that a man is not running, and a gallop says that he is. Behind them, Ellis the deputy stood in the doorway of the jailhouse, and Brandt's riders, who had been waiting in the shade, watched them go, and one of them spat in the dust, and the other did not move at all.
On the trail home, Sam spoke for the first time since the hearing ended. "Did you see Brandt's face when Cole put his hand on that paper?" he asked. "He looked like a man who had been caught stealing and was already thinking of what he would steal next."
I saw it, Corvin said. "That is why we will not sleep easy tonight. A man like Brandt does not stop because he is caught. He stops when he has nothing left to try, and he still has riders, and he still has money, and he still has a claim he has not yet invented."
Aiyana rode between them, and the wind moved her hair, and she said, "Then we will be ready for whatever he invents. We have a ledger. We have a sheriff. We have each other. That is more than he has, because he has only men he pays, and paid men leave when the pay stops."