They went back, then, together, into the room. It had been above a bakery on a street whose name neither of them said aloud even now, out of a loyalty so old it had become reflex — up an unmarked stair, past a door with no sign and a lock that Bea changed every spring. No mirrors. That was the first thing everyone remembered wrong about such places, Ruth said; people imagined vanity, mirrors and photographs, but Bea had banned mirrors in the second year. You will learn where your body is by where it is, she had said, not by watching it be somewhere. Mats that smelled of canvas and winter. A kettle. A shelf of books, actual books, which Bea had required of them with the same seriousness as the drills — a novel a month, argued over, because a fighter who cannot read a room, she said, in every sense of the phrase, is a danger to herself and a bore to everyone else. That was where the promoters' name had come from, though they never knew it: not the quiet, but the books. Seven women reading on the rest days with their bandaged hands, exact about everything.
"She used to stand at the end of the mat," Imani said, "with her arms folded, and if you did a thing only to be seen doing it, she would not scold you. She would just look at the place where the technique should have been. Like you'd left a gap on a shelf."
"Skill is a library," Ruth said.
"You don't burn it down to prove you can read," Imani finished, and they were both quiet, because it was the closest thing either of them had to a prayer, and because the woman who had written it on their lives had been dead since 2011 and there was no one left to be embarrassed in front of.
They talked for two hours. The light went out of Imani's kitchen and she did not turn the lamp on. Ruth spoke of the night the promoter had come — she would save that telling, she said, because it was Imani's story to open, not hers; she had only been the one standing second from the left when it happened, and history owed the first person the first telling. But she said this: "I want you to know, since you have carried a particular piece of it. When you refused, you did not ask us first. You want to remember that correctly. You stood up in that dreadful office and you said no in your own name only, and the rest of us stood up after — each in her own name — because you had made it possible to stand. Bea said afterwards that it was the finest sequence you ever performed and it had no technique in it at all."
"I have wondered," Imani said, carefully, "whether I spent you all. Whether the Cohort died of my no."
"It died of its own rules," Ruth said, with the finality of a woman closing a register. "It was built to end rather than be owned. You merely read the terms aloud. Do not promote yourself to villain in a story that doesn't have one, Imani Carter. It has a promoter. That's a different thing — and he is not worth the promotion either."
When the call was ending — reluctantly, item by item, the way old soldiers and old librarians both take their leave — Ruth said she still had Bea's notebook. The black one, with the brackets drawn in pencil and the margins full of handwriting like a second, smaller book arguing with the first. She had kept it in a drawer through three house moves, under the good table linen, because Bea had given it to her the last winter with instructions that had seemed, for seventeen years, impossible to follow: Give it to whichever of you is found first. "I did not understand it," Ruth said. "I thought it was one of her riddles. It wasn't a riddle. It was a fixture list. She knew one of us would be found, and she knew it would be in public, and she wanted the book to travel." A pause, dry as paper. "I believe, my dear, that the grandson with the phone has settled the fixture."
"Keep it a little longer," Imani said. Her voice was not steady and she did not hide it. "Until I know what I'm doing. I don't know what I'm doing, Ruth. A boy did a trick at me in a hall and the whole closed book has started — falling open at the spine."
"Then let it fall open at the spine," Ruth said. "That's how the best ones finally open. Call me when there's news. And Imani — " the gravel softened, all the way down to the girl who had once shared a mat and a kettle and a secret — "it was worth the seventeen years to hear you laugh like that. Bea used to say you'd be the last of us to be found. She did not say you'd be found hiding. Remember the difference, because I intend to hold you to it."