She told Paula the whole of it that evening, on the telephone, standing in her kitchen with her sleeves rolled to the elbow. Paula laughed once, in the middle, at the shelving comparison, and then was quiet in the particular way Paula was quiet when she was copying something into the permanent file of her mind.
"The district will be devastated to lose the shelving," Paula said. "Tell me about the catalogue, then."
The catalogue was Ruth's idea, though Ruth would deny it under oath and did, twice, in writing. It began with the brackets. In the Cohort's competing years there had been no published roster and almost no photographs, but there had been brackets — the paper architecture of every event, results grids in promoters' pencil, initials only, C., K., D., A., R., J., and C. again, the second C. distinguished by a small star Bea had drawn and no one had ever decoded to anyone outside the room. The brackets had survived in the way paper survives when somebody loves it: in Bea's notebook, in Ruth's flat in Philadelphia, in a tin box that had moved house eleven times without ever being opened in daylight.
There were seven names. There had always been exactly seven names, one for each point of the numeral, as Bea used to say when she was in a rare fanciful mood and the room pretended not to hear the softness in it. Three of the seven were still living: Imani, and Ruth, and June Okafor — no relation to anyone but herself, as she announced on the telephone from Toronto, in a voice like a struck match — who had coached three decades of wrestlers and had opinions about digitisation. Four were gone: Bea in 2011, and two more to the ordinary attritions of years, and one, in 2009, in a car on an icy road in Ohio, whose daughter answered Ruth's letter in handwriting so like her mother's that Ruth had to sit down.
The rule of the project was set before the first page was scanned, and it was Imani who set it, and Ruth who seconded it, and June who called it the first sensible sentence spoken about the Cohort in twenty-four years: no name would be restored without consent. The living would be asked. The dead would be asked for, through their families, with the same question and the same freedom to refuse it. Anyone who said no would remain an initial forever, honoured exactly as written, and the archive would carry the refusal with the same care as the names. A record, Imani said, is not a net. You don't get to drag people into history because you've finally learned how to spell them.
By November they had six consents and one beautiful, considered silence from the Ohio family, which they filed, unscanned and unphotographed, as an initial and a star. June flew down for a weekend and spent it arguing happily with Ruth's scanner. Paula gave the project the expo's spare office and its good paper shredder for the duplicates, because an archive, she said, is mostly the discipline of what you throw away. The brackets went up page by page into the light: pencil brightened, initials matched to hands, the small star finally explained by June, laughing, in the margin of the scan — it had marked the woman who brought the oranges. It had always marked the woman who brought the oranges. Bea's sentiment, kept in code for twenty-four years, turned out to be about fruit.
The letter to Ohio took Imani eleven drafts, which Ruth, informed by telephone, considered showing off. It said who was writing, and why, and what was being asked, and — in a sentence Imani wrote first and defended against every subsequent draft — that no answer would also be received as an answer, with thanks. She did not send the bracket page, or the one photograph of the seven of them in a line, laughing at something outside the frame. You do not open a negotiation with somebody's mother at twenty-six, surprised by joy. She sent the letter on plain paper, from the library, and waited the way seventeen years of interlibrary loans had trained her to wait: without refreshing anything, in the faith that the post knew its business.