Frank Delaney had built houses for thirty-eight years. He had started as a laborer at eighteen, carrying lumber and digging footings, and retired at sixty-two as a man other contractors called when something had to be done right. He had built the deck on the Hendersons' house three doors down. He had re-roofed half the street after the hailstorm in 2009. His hands were permanently shaped by the work, the fingers slightly bent, the knuckles enlarged, and he looked at other people's construction the way Lisa looked at other people's wounds: automatically, diagnostically, and with opinions.
He had lived next door to the Harpers for twelve years and next door to Harlan Beck for eighteen years before that, thirty years in the same house on Sycamore Lane. He had watched Emma Harper grow from a small fierce child who rode a tricycle into his rose bed — he had never mentioned the tricycle; Carol had laughed about it for a week — into a tall teenager who waved at him from the bus stop. He had watched David Harper put up a swing set and take it down again. He had watched Lisa Harper come home from night shifts and stand at her kitchen window with coffee, the way she was standing now, probably, though he did not look.
Frank's house was the mirror image of the Harpers', another 1960s ranch, but where the Harper house had the comfortable clutter of a family still in motion, Frank's house had the stillness of a man who had finished most of his projects. Carol's armchair was still in the living room. Her gardening gloves still hung on the peg by the back door. Frank had not moved them in five years, and Ruth had stopped suggesting that he might.
Ruth Delaney was thirty-eight, a paralegal who lived across town with her husband and Grace. She came on weekends, usually Saturdays, and she spent those visits doing what daughters do: checking the refrigerator, eyeing the gutters, asking her father questions he did not want to answer.
"Dad," she had said the previous Saturday, standing in his kitchen with her hands on her hips, "when are you going to do something about that fence?"
Frank had been washing a mug. "What about it?"
"It's falling down. The middle section leans like a drunk."
"It's stood for thirty years."
"It's stood for thirty years and now it leans." Ruth had taken the mug from him and dried it. "You're a contractor. You of all people shouldn't live with a leaning fence."
Frank had not answered, because the fence was not a subject he discussed. The fence was a subject he carried.
What Ruth did not know — what no one knew, because Frank had never said it aloud in thirty years — was that every time he looked at that cedar fence, he saw his father. Not the fence itself, but what it had cost. His father, a careful man who had saved for everything and borrowed for nothing, had lent three thousand dollars to Harlan Beck in 1989 to pay for the original fence, and Harlan Beck had never paid it back. Frank's father had died twelve years later, and on one of his last clear days he had said to Frank, "That Beck never paid me for the fence," and Frank had said, "I know, Dad," and his father had said, "Somebody ought to set that right."
Frank had carried that sentence for thirty years. He had carried it through his working life, through Carol's illness, through the quiet years after. And somewhere along the way, without his quite deciding it, the grievance had attached itself not to Harlan Beck — who had sold the house and moved to Florida and died there — but to the boundary itself. The fence. The line. The two feet of earth that, in Frank's private accounting, had never been properly settled.
He did not think of it as a grudge. He thought of it as an unfinished job. And Frank Delaney did not leave jobs unfinished.
So on the second Saturday of April, Frank called a fence contractor he knew from the old days, a man named Pete Kowalski who owed him a favor from a roofing job in 2011, and he said, "Pete, I need a fence replaced. Cedar, like for like. And I need it done right."
Pete said, "When?"
"Next week," Frank said. "And Pete — I want it on the true line. Not where the old one drifted. The true line."
There was a pause. Pete, who had known Frank for thirty years, said carefully, "You sure about the true line, Frank?"
"I'm sure," Frank said. "Thirty years ago Harlan Beck and I — Harlan Beck shook my hand on it. The true line is two feet east of where that old fence sits. Everybody knows the old fence drifted."
This was not true. Nobody knew any such thing, because no such handshake had ever happened. But Frank had told the story to himself so many times, in the garage, in the yard, in the long evenings after Carol died, that it had acquired the texture of memory. He believed it the way people believe the stories that explain their pain.
Pete said, "Okay, Frank. Your fence, your call. I'll pull the crew together."
Frank hung up and stood in his kitchen for a long time, looking out at the backyard, at Carol's roses, at the leaning cedar fence. He felt, for the first time in years, like a man with a plan.