David came home early, which he almost never did, and the three Harpers went out to the backyard with a tape measure, a ball of twine, and the grim purposefulness of a family conducting a scientific investigation.
They started at the old fence's remaining sections, which still stood at either end of the torn-down middle stretch, and they ran the twine along the line the old posts had marked. Then they measured from the twine to the new post holes.
"Twenty-three inches," David said at the first hole. "Twenty-four at the second. Twenty-three and a half at the third." He looked up. "Call it two feet."
Emma stood with her arms crossed. "I told you."
"You did," Lisa said. "Good eyes."
They stood there in the April afternoon, the three of them, looking at the dark holes in their yard. From Frank's garage came the sound of a radio, a baseball game, ordinary and oblivious.
"What did he say, exactly?" David asked.
"He said there was a thirty-year-old handshake deal with Harlan Beck. That the true line is two feet east of the old fence. That the old fence drifted."
David frowned. "Fences don't drift, Lisa. Posts rot and lean, but a fence line doesn't migrate two feet."
"I know that."
"And Harlan Beck sold us this house twelve years ago and never mentioned any handshake deal."
"I know that too."
David was quiet for a moment, coiling the twine. David's quiet had layers, and Lisa, after twenty years of marriage, could read most of them. This was his thinking quiet.
"Our deed describes the lot," he said. "But deeds describe; surveys draw. If there's a real question about the line, what we need is the original subdivision survey. The county records office will have it."
"And in the meantime?"
"In the meantime, we ask him, in writing, to stop work until the line is confirmed. Polite, factual, documented."
Lisa nodded. This was why she had married him. In the ER, Lisa was the one who stayed calm. At home, David was the one who made plans.
Emma said, "Grace is going to be so upset."
Lisa looked at her daughter. "Have you talked to her?"
"She texted me a picture of the holes. She said her grandpa's been weird about the fence for weeks. She said — " Emma hesitated. "She said he's been talking about her great-grandfather. About money. She doesn't really understand it either."
Lisa felt something cold move in her chest. Money. She filed it away.
"Emma," she said, "I need you to know something. Your dad and I are going to handle this with Frank directly, adult to adult. You do not have to choose sides, and Grace does not have to choose sides, and your friendship is not part of this dispute. Okay?"
Emma nodded, but she looked unconvinced, and Lisa didn't blame her. Promises about not choosing sides were easy to make and hard to keep, and both of them knew it.
That evening, Lisa wrote the letter. She wrote it the way she wrote incident reports: clear, chronological, without adjectives.
"Dear Frank," she wrote. "This afternoon I noticed that the post holes for your new fence are approximately two feet east of the existing fence line, on what David and I have always understood to be our property. You mentioned a handshake agreement with the previous owner regarding the boundary. We were not aware of any such agreement when we purchased the house twelve years ago. I am asking you, as our neighbor, to pause construction until we can confirm the boundary line together. David is obtaining the original subdivision survey from the county records office. I have enclosed a copy of our deed for your reference. I hope we can resolve this as neighbors. Sincerely, Lisa."
She printed two copies, signed both, and walked one over to Frank's front door at seven o'clock. She rang the bell. Frank answered, looked at the envelope, and took it without a word.
"Frank," Lisa said. "Please read it. Please don't set the posts in concrete until we know where the line is."
Frank held the envelope. For a moment, something moved in his face — something that might have been doubt, or might have been grief. Then the set expression returned.
"I know where the line is," he said, and closed the door.
Lisa walked home across the damp grass. In the morning, she watched from her kitchen window as Pete Kowalski's crew poured concrete into the post holes.
Chapter 5: Emma in the Middle
The new fence went up fast. Cedar was Frank's medium — he had worked with it all his life — and Pete Kowalski's crew was efficient. By Friday of that week, a twenty-foot run of fresh, honey-colored cedar stood where the weathered gray fence had been, and it stood two feet inside the Harper yard, as straight as a ruler and as wrong, to Lisa's eyes, as a bone set crooked.
She had called the county records office on Wednesday. The clerk had been helpful in the way of people who deal with the public all day: patient, precise, and faintly resigned.
"Subdivision survey for Sycamore Lane, 1987?" the clerk had said. "That'll be in the plat books. Your husband can come look at it anytime. If he wants a certified copy, that's fifteen dollars."