Emma and Grace came home from school at three-thirty and stood at the edge of the work area, and after a while Emma went inside and came back out with a pitcher of lemonade and two stacks of plastic cups, and Grace carried them over to the workers, and the girls stood there, suddenly shy, offering lemonade to men with tool belts, and the men took the cups and thanked them, and one of them — a young guy with a sunburned neck — said, "You girls the reason we're doing this twice?" and Emma said, very seriously, "We're the reason for a lot of things," and the crew laughed, and Lisa saw Frank watching the girls, and saw his face do something complicated.
Later, when the crew was stacking the lumber in Frank's driveway — his half and the Harpers' half in two neat piles, because Frank was precise about such things — Emma and Grace sat on the Harpers' back steps with the empty pitcher between them, and they were talking quietly, the way they used to before April, heads bent together, and Lisa felt something in her shoulders let go that she hadn't known was still holding on.
"They're going to be okay," David said, coming up behind her.
"The girls were always going to be okay," Lisa said. "It was us I was worried about."
David put his arm around her waist. Across the yard, Frank was running his hand along the top board of one of the lumber stacks, and Ruth had come over — it was a Tuesday, but she had taken the afternoon off too — and she was talking to him, and he was nodding, and Lisa thought about the framed note, which was going up in Frank's garage that weekend, and about the plaque, which Ruth had ordered, and which would read, in simple engraved letters, the words they had all agreed on: his father's name, the dates, and underneath, "He helped build this fence."
Chapter 24: The Rose Bed
With the moved fence down, the backyards lay open to each other for the first time in months — two long rectangles of grass with the orange-ribboned survey stakes standing in a straight, undeniable line between them, two feet from where Frank's fence had been.
And there, on Frank's side of the true line, exactly where it had always been, was the rose bed.
Lisa stood at her kitchen window that evening, washing the dinner dishes, and she looked out, and she saw it clearly for the first time in weeks: the neat rectangle of dark soil, the rose bushes his late wife — Helen, who had died five years ago — had planted and tended, the new growth coming in strong, a few early buds showing color. It had always been on Frank's side. The survey proved it. Nobody had ever disputed it. But seeing it there, with the fence gone and the line staked in orange, Lisa understood something she hadn't fully understood before: Frank had been tending that bed through the entire dispute, every evening, with extra care, as if the roses were the one thing he could still control.
She watched him now. He was out there in the long evening light, kneeling on the old foam pad he used, deadheading the spent blooms with his fingers, gentle in a way she had never seen him be gentle. He talked to the roses — she couldn't hear the words, but she could see his lips moving, the way people talk to plants and pets and the dead.
Something loosened in Lisa's chest. She had been angry at Frank for so long — for the two feet, for the silence, for the contractor's truck in April — and the anger had changed shape in the mediation room, and now, watching him with his wife's roses, it changed shape again, into something like grief. Not her grief. His. Five years a widower, thirty years carrying his father's hurt, and the roses, and the fence, and all of it tangled together like roots.
David came into the kitchen and stood beside her, drying a plate.
"He's been out there every night," David said quietly.
"I know," Lisa said. "Grace told Emma he cries sometimes. When he thinks no one's listening."
David was quiet for a moment. Then he said, "I think about what Ruth said. About the promise he made his father. Can you imagine? Carrying that for thirty years. Every time he looked at that fence."
"I carried my part for three months and it nearly broke me," Lisa said. "Thirty years — " She shook her head. "No wonder he moved it. I'm not saying it was right. But I understand it now. It wasn't about the two feet. It was never about the two feet."
They watched together for a while, not speaking, the dishwater cooling in the sink, and then Frank stood up, slowly, the way a sixty-four-year-old man stands up from kneeling, brushing the soil from his knees, and he looked across the open yards, and he saw them in the window, and Lisa braced herself — but Frank just lifted one hand, a small wave, and went back inside his house.
Lisa waved back, even though he couldn't see it through the glass. Or maybe he could.
That night, lying in bed, Lisa thought about Helen Delaney, whom she had known only slightly — a kind woman with flour on her hands who had once brought over a casserole when Lisa had the flu, years ago. She thought about the rose bed, and about Frank kneeling in the dirt, talking to his dead wife's flowers, and she thought about how little any of us know about what our neighbors are carrying, and how much easier it is to measure a boundary than to ask about a grief.