towel and the expression of a woman who has decided a thing and will not be
reasoned with by its absurdity, and it became, within the week, a rotation: a
printed schedule, names in pencil, dishes arriving at the boathouse stairs on
Tuesdays and Fridays in labeled foil with reheating instructions in three
different hands. Walt owned a boathouse loft, a binder, and an
eleven-million-dollar insurance claim, and the year-round population of
Cedar Bluff took up a collection of lasagnas for him, and the absurdity of it
was so complete that he accepted it whole, the way you accept weather —
because he understood, standing at the door with a tuna bake going cold in
his hands, that the casseroles were not about food. They were ballots. Every
foil dish on the boathouse stairs was a household declaring, in the only
currency that could not be minuted or subpoenaed, which newspaper it read.
He ate the casseroles in order. He washed the dishes and returned them with
thank-you notes written in his inventory hand. He recorded the rotation in the
binder — cooks, dates, dishes — because recording was what he did with
anything that mattered, and because forty years in freight had taught him that
a manifest, kept honestly, is a kind of love letter that never has to say so.
Hank Ostrander himself came down to the dock on the first clear Saturday of
December, where Walt was helping a neighbor winch a sailboat cradle out of
the shallows before the ice took it, and stood with his hands in his coat and
his breath smoking, watching the water go slate and gold under the low sun.
"You know how it stands," Hank said. It was not a question.
67
"I hear versions," Walt said.
"Here's the version from the end of the dock." Hank nodded toward the point,
toward the big houses with their glass lit early against the dark coming down.
"Half this lake thinks you hired it done, Walt, because the other half can't
stand the arithmetic of it being her. Give them time. Ash settles slower than
water." He said it without cruelty, as a report, the way a man reads a
barometer he doesn't blame for the reading. "Meantime, you eat the tuna
bake. My wife's feelings are a strategic asset and I won't have them spent on
a man who won't take seconds."
"I took seconds," Walt said.
"Then the alliance holds," Hank said, and they went back to the winch, and
the cradle came up out of the lake bed with a sucking sound and a year of
weed on its runners, and neither of them said anything more that mattered,
which Walt had come to understand was the dock's whole editorial policy:
say the true thing once, plainly, and then go back to work beside a man so he
can hear it settle.
The grand jury returned its indictment in the week before Christmas, on a
day when the lake had skinned over at the edges and the year-round houses
had their lights on by four. Salter had the news first, being Salter, and then
Drexler called at dusk to confirm it in the official voice: conspiracy to
commit arson; arson in the second degree; the State of the proceedings
against Gail Thornton, president of the Cedar Bluff association, of the point.
Walt took the call standing in the boathouse loft with a dish towel over his
shoulder, interrupted at the washing of a returned casserole dish, and he set
the dish down carefully and listened to the charges arrange themselves, and
found that what he felt was mostly an attention to detail — the towel still
damp in his hand, the light going down outside the glass, the investigator's
68
voice using the word defendant in a sentence with her name in it at last.
Salter said the arrest would be early and quiet, and that Tanaka's office had
no interest in a spectacle. Walt said he understood, and finished washing the
dish, because a thing returned clean is a thing returned properly, and there
was nothing else in the evening that was his to do.
Drexler called again at five-fifty the next morning, before the light, and said
only: "Mr. Hennessy, I thought you'd want to hear it from a man and not a
feed. They're at the Thornton house now."
Walt put on water for coffee he did not drink and stood at the loft window in
the dark with his coat over his nightclothes, and watched the point across the
water do what the whole winter population of Cedar Bluff was watching it do
from behind its own glass. The cruisers had come without lights down the
shore road and now stood in the Thorntons' drive with their running lights
on, breathing exhaust into the cold; the house's windows lit one by one, floor
by floor, as rooms were entered; and along the dark shore, in house after
house, other windows kindled, early and yellow, the small audience of a lake
that had read about itself in the county paper for two months and now had a
dawn performance. After some time — he did not time it; it was one of the
few intervals since the fire that he declined to measure — the front door
opened and Gail Thornton came out between two deputies in a long coat
thrown over her nightclothes, with her hair down and her chin up, and got
into the back of a cruiser with the dignity of a woman boarding a train she