each one itemized, each one serene — there remained the matter of his fines.
Eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars, assessed across the
summer by Gail Thornton's standards committee for violations that had never
survived ten honest minutes of daylight: the dock lights, the shoreline
plantings, the guest house occupancy, the flag. He had never paid a dollar of
it. He did not pay a dollar of it now, with eleven million in transit and the
fines amounting to a rounding error's rounding error. He wrote the figure in
the notebook, in the column where it had lived since August, and left it there,
open. The money was never the argument. The argument was that the fines
had been written by a process that answered to one woman's will, and paying
them — at any amount, at any discount, for any reason — would have been
his signature on the bottom of her version of events. He had just signed a
great deal of paper that week. He knew the weight of a signature. That one he
was saving.
The board broke in January, ten days after Novak's visit, and it broke the way
ice breaks on the lake in a thaw — not all at once but along lines of stress
75
that had been audible for months.
The first motion, back in December, had failed four to three: suspend the
president pending the outcome of the criminal matter, seat the vice president,
conduct the association's business at arm's length from the indictment. Four
to three the board had stood by Gail Thornton — her appointees, her
majority, the architecture of eleven years — and the county paper had
recorded the vote in two sentences and the gate chat had metabolized it into
the usual weather. But an indictment is not weather. An indictment is a
document, and documents accumulate. A president of Cedar Bluff under
indictment for conspiracy to commit arson and arson in the second degree —
for burning a resident's house, a member's house, a house inside the gates she
was elected to keep safe — was a fact that sat in the community's throat
every time a board letter went out over a signature block that still carried her
title. The treasurer, who had voted with her in December, brought the motion
a second time in January, and this time he brought it with the association's
own counsel's written opinion attached, twelve pages about fiduciary
exposure that used the word untenable the way other men used salt. The
motion carried five to two. The vice president took the chair for the
remainder of the meeting and adjourned it in eleven minutes, and the
minutes, when they were posted, recorded the whole earthquake in the flat
prose of procedure, which Walt read three times with the satisfaction of a
man reading a manifest that finally matched the freight.
The membership moved next, the way the membership was entitled to move
and so rarely bothered to. A recall required a petition of fifty members in
good standing. The petition that reached the association office in the last
week of January carried sixty-one signatures, gathered in nine days, at
kitchen tables and dock ends and the library fund's winter book sale, and it
76
called a special meeting for February with one item of business. Walt's
signature was not on it. He had been asked — twice, once by a neighbor
whose decency he had never doubted and once by a man who had voted for
every fine Gail ever levied on him and now wanted to be photographed on
the right side of the correction — and he had declined both times,
courteously, with the same sentence: "It's the community's paper. It ought to
carry the community's names, not the plaintiff's." What he did not say was
that he had spent the autumn learning what a document became when the
interested party's hand was visible on it. The petition would be stronger
without him. He could wait.
The Thorntons did not wait. In the second week of February, five nights
before the special meeting, the clubhouse hosted what the notice in the
mailboxes called a community information night — no official business, no
votes, refreshments provided — and Roger Thornton stood up in front of the
fireplace in a blazer with the association's burgee stitched small over the
pocket and made the best case that could be made, and Walt, sitting in the
third row with his hands folded, listened to it the way he had listened to
Novak: completely, and without the courtesy of interruption.
It was not a bad case. That was the thing nobody at the lake said aloud
afterward, and the thing Walt understood best of anyone in the room, because
he had spent his career watching professionals construct the strongest
available account of a bad set of facts. Roger's account was this. His wife's
text — the text the whole county could now recite, sent at nine forty-two on
the night before the fire, Tomorrow night fixes the Ridgeline problem, make
sure it's clean — was a text about a filing. The Ridgeline Townes paperwork
was due at the county that week; that was true, and Roger had the county's
stamped calendar to prove it, and he passed the calendar down the front row
77
like an exhibit, because he was a developer and developers understand that
paper passed hand to hand acquires weight. The text said clean, and clean
was what you said about a filing you wanted complete and correct, and if the
prosecution wanted the word to mean a crime scene, the prosecution would