young man, who had clearly been briefed that the address was difficult,
9
looked at the most famous driveway in the estates and said the office had
asked for hand delivery on account of the paperwork being time-sensitive.
"Everything from the committee is time-sensitive," Walt said. "It's fined by
the day. A thing that charges by the day can't afford to travel slowly." The
young man almost smiled, and then remembered his polo shirt, and did not.
He took the coffee anyway, standing at the boathouse rail, and Walt watched
him look — the way everyone looked, the first time, and most people the
fiftieth — at the glass wall and the cove and the long empty meadow running
down to the road, and he had the uncharitable and probably accurate thought
that the committee's whole summer could be explained by that look, if you
were willing to believe that envy could be taught to fill out forms. He did not
say it. He asked after the young man's family, learned he had a baby coming,
and sent him back up the drive with the envelope's twin — his own one
courteous page, already written, already copied, because by August Walt was
drafting his replies before the citations arrived, the way a depot manager
pre-loads a truck for a route he has run too many times to pretend it is new.
By the end of August the summer's total, computed on the association's own
letters, stood at eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars. Walt paid
none of it. He answered every notice with a single page, courteous to the
syllable, and a copy of the relevant permit, and he filed the whole
correspondence in a binder whose spine he had labeled in his logistics hand
— the square, unhurried capitals he had used on warehouse manifests for
thirty years: CEDAR BLUFF — COST OF COOPERATION. The binder
lived on the kitchen counter, where he could see it while the coffee brewed.
It was getting thick enough to need a second ring. He found he did not mind
looking at it. A fine you can file is a fine you can see the size of, and
eighteen thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars, against a meadow priced
at three point three million and an option clock ticking on the Thorntons'
10
forty acres, was not a revenue program. It was a message being delivered at
retail because wholesale had failed.
The neighbors, as neighbors do, divided their counsel along the seam of their
own experience. At the gas dock a man named Prescott, who had been on the
board and off it again, advised him in the tone of a veteran of a war he had
lost on points to simply pay and be left alone, that it was cheaper than being
right, that everybody eventually learned the lake's arithmetic. Walt thanked
him and bought his gas. But Hank and Ruth Ostrander, whose house sat two
coves down and whose dock Walt's boat drifted past on the evenings he let it
drift, asked him to tie up one August night and fed him catfish and told him,
without prompting, about their gazebo.
"Two years ago," Ruth said, "the committee decided our gazebo was the
wrong white."
"There's more than one white?" June would have asked. Walt asked it for
her.
"There are four whites," Hank said. "Ours was the fifth. Fifteen dollars a day
until we painted it the third white, which is the one it already was if you held
the chip up in the right light, but we painted it, Walt. We painted a white
gazebo white. And Ruth is right, and I want you to hear me — we still taste
it. Two years later. Not the money. The painting."
"We paid to be left alone," Ruth said, "and it turns out being left alone isn't in
the catalog. They don't sell that. They sell you the next letter."
Walt sat with the catfish and the darkening water and the two of them, who
had been on the lake longer than he had and had paid their toll like everyone,
and he understood that the Ostranders were not advising him. They were
confessing to him, which is the thing people on a lake do when they have
11
decided a man is one of theirs. He thanked them and meant it. On the slow
idle home, with the binder's arithmetic running unbidden in his head, he said
it aloud to the empty boat, the sentence he had been carrying around since
the spring, since the folder on the deck: "A house is just weather, arranged
politely. Land is the only thing they can't burn."
He had not meant it as anything more than a logistics man's epitaph for the
whole argument. Property could be fined, cited, shaded wrong, lit
excessively, re-examined comprehensively. The meadow just lay there, being
the meadow, costing nobody anything, appreciating in the deep unhurried
way of level ground on water. He said it and the boat's wake said it back and
he thought no more of it that night than a man thinks of the weather he has
arranged politely around his life.
It was in September, doing the thing he did every few years whether it
needed doing or not, that he re-read his title file.
The habit came from the company. Every load checked, every contract
re-read on the anniversary of its signing, because Walt had learned at
twenty-six, at a cost he had never repeated, that paper does not stay the way