He stood in the motor pool office and told me, in front of witnesses, that the trucks he wanted were surely somewhere on the lot, and that my reluctance to produce them was a failure of imagination. He said it as if imagination were a supply category. He smiled when he said it, the way a man smiles when he believes he has just been clever and kind at the same time.
I did not argue with his rank. I showed him the inventory.
It was not a dramatic document. It was a list, dated, signed, with serial numbers and conditions and locations, and it did not contain the vehicles he wanted because those vehicles did not exist on any inventory I was allowed to sign for. You cannot issue what you do not have, and you cannot invent a truck by wanting one hard enough. He read the list twice, which I took as a compliment to the list, and then he left without the trucks and without, I think, quite the same smile.
Years later, in civilian life, a contractor arrived at a city building with a clipboard, a confidence that bordered on theatre, and an invoice for work his crew had photographed but not performed. The photographs were good. They showed clean work, finished work, work that would have been a credit to anyone who had actually done it. The problem was that the work in the photographs was not the work in the building. The pipes were still old where the photographs showed them new. The seals were still cracked where the photographs showed them replaced.
He talked well. He talked about standards and completion and professionalism, and he waved the clipboard as if it were a witness. I showed him the inspection log.
The log was duller than his invoice and less flattering, which is usually how you can tell it is true. It had dates and times and initials and notes in my handwriting about what I had actually seen, room by room, on the days I had actually been there. Photographs can be borrowed. A log, kept day by day, is harder to borrow, because it has to agree with itself across weeks. His invoice did not agree with the building. The log did. He left with his clipboard and without his payment, at least not that day, and not on those terms.
The third man was a council member who believed a three-hour answer was more dignified than a true one. He was not a bad man, exactly. He was a man who had learned that if you talked long enough, most people stopped listening closely enough to notice that you had not answered. He once filibustered his own question until the stenographer looked up in quiet despair. I remember that look because it was so unprofessional and so human at the same time: a woman whose job was to write down words, confronted with a flood of them that meant nothing, wondering whether she was supposed to record the flood anyway. She did. That was her job.
Each of those men believed the world should rearrange itself around the fact of his wanting. The colonel wanted trucks, so trucks should exist. The contractor wanted payment, so work should be considered done. The council member wanted dignity, so length should count as substance. Each discovered, eventually, that wanting is not a document.
I did not take pleasure in those discoveries. I took notes. Notes, I had learned, were what remained after the wanting faded, and they were what I would need when the next man arrived with a louder version of the same idea.
There was a discipline to showing paper instead of raising a voice, and it was harder than it looked. It required you to stay calm while another man performed certainty, to let him finish his performance, and then to place a flat, uninteresting document on the table as if it were the most interesting thing in the room. It usually was. A document does not flatter, does not threaten, and does not get tired. It simply says what it says, and it says it the same way the second time you read it, which is more than can be said for most men who want something badly.
Entitlement is not really about things. That took me longer to learn than the inventory lesson, because things are visible and entitlement is not, and it is easy to mistake the first for the second.