HOA Karen Called Cops When I Refused To Give Her Free Gas — Unaware Who I Really Was

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Brenda came to the workshop in daylight, which was a change. Until then, her moves had mostly arrived by letter, or by someone else's hands, or after dark. This time she drove up in the middle of a Saturday morning, parked in my driveway without asking, and walked straight to the open workshop door with her chin up and her voice already raised.

"Frank," she said, before she was even fully inside. "We need to talk about this tank, and we need to talk about it now, because this community cannot have a private fuel depot in the middle of a neighborhood."

I was at the bench with the Chevrolet's transmission parts laid out in order on a clean rag. Buster got up from his bed and stood beside me, watching her. I wiped my hands on a shop towel and did not raise my voice. Volume, I have learned, is usually what a person uses when the paper has run out.

"Morning, Brenda," I said. "Come in, if you're coming in peacefully. The tank is private property. It's on my deed. That's not a position. That's a fact."

She did not sit down. She stood in the middle of the workshop floor and talked over me, or tried to. She said the tank was a safety hazard. She said the neighbors were afraid. She said the HOA had a responsibility to the community, and that my refusal to share the fuel was selfish, and that the fines would continue until I complied. Each claim arrived louder than the last, as if volume could make a claim true by repetition.

I let her finish each one before I answered, because interrupting a person who is shouting only gives them a reason to shout louder. When she said safety hazard, I walked to the binder, opened it to Karen Liu's inspection reports, and held up the clearance letter. "The fire marshal inspected it twice," I said. "She cleared it a third time in writing after your complaint. That's the county's judgment, not mine."

When she said community reserve, I turned to the deed copy and the survey. "Page forty-one of the closing packet," I said. "The tank, the containment, and the pump conveyed with the property. Harold Wendell owned it, and I bought it from his estate. There is no community interest in it."

When she said the agreement, I turned to the page where I had noted the problems with her so-called community fuel agreement: the signature that did not match Harold Wendell's, the date after his death, the absence of any record in the county or the HOA files. "A paper dated after a man died," I said, "is not an agreement. It's a problem, and it's not my problem to solve by handing over fuel."

She stared at the binder as if it were a person who had insulted her. I could see her looking for a way around it, and not finding one, because there was no way around a document except another document, and she did not have one. She raised her voice once more, about the fines, about the board, about what the neighborhood would think, but the words landed differently now, thinner, because each one had already been answered by a page she could read if she wanted to.

"I came here for a reasonable conversation," she said at last, though it had not been reasonable and it had not been a conversation.

"You came for a nod," I said, quietly. "I can't give you one. The paper doesn't give me room to."

She looked at me, at Buster, at the transmission parts in their neat row, and then she turned and walked out without another word. Her car door shut harder than it needed to. I watched her back out of the driveway and drive away, and I stood in the workshop doorway until the sound of her engine was gone.

Then I went back to the bench, washed my hands again, and wrote it down: Brenda Ashworth, workshop, daylight, claims answered with deed, survey, and fire marshal clearance. She left without the nod she came for. Paper holds. I wrote that last sentence again, because it was becoming a habit, and habits, in a fight like this, are what keep a man from shouting back.

The fines arrived the way weather arrives in this part of the county: first one, then a few, then so many you stopped counting the sky and started counting the roof. The first was for unauthorized fuel storage. The second was for refusal to comply with a community directive. The third was for failure to grant access to a community reserve. After that, they came in envelopes with the HOA letterhead and Brenda Ashworth's signature, each one citing a rule that sounded official until you looked for it in the actual covenants and found nothing underneath it.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Called Cops When I Refused To Give Her Free Gas — Unaware Who I Really Was

45 Part