At dawn, I did my usual walk: out the back door, past the workshop, to the tank. Buster came with me, trotting ahead and then stopping, his nose up, his body suddenly alert in a way that told me something had changed before I saw it myself. I stopped beside him and looked.
The pump lock had been cut again. Not the same lock — I had replaced the first one — but a new cut, clean through the shackle, in the same place, with the same kind of tool mark. Beside the pump, on the ground inside the containment area, were two fuel cans, the red plastic kind, one tipped on its side, the other upright with its cap off. The ground near the tank showed fresh footprints in the dew, leading from the side fence toward the pump and back again.
I did not touch anything. That was the first rule I had set for myself after the first cut, and it was the rule that mattered most now. I stood back, took a breath, and went inside for the camera and the phone, leaving Buster at the workshop door with a command to stay. He stayed, watching me, his ears up, as if he understood that this morning was different from other mornings.
I photographed everything before I touched anything: the cut lock where it lay, the cans, the footprints, the pump, the sign, the tank from three angles, the fence line where the footprints began. I photographed wide and then close, the way Deputy Bell had photographed the first scene, because a wide shot tells you where you are and a close shot tells you what happened. I checked the time on each photograph as I took it, and I wrote the times down in the logbook, along with the date and the fact that nothing had been moved.
Then I went inside and reviewed the camera footage on the workshop monitor. It was Scott Pruitt. There was no doubt about it, and no need to guess. The camera caught him coming over the side fence just after two, carrying the cans, walking straight to the pump with the confidence of a man who had done this before. It caught him working at the lock, the tool flashing in the camera's night light, and it caught him filling one can, or trying to, before he stopped, looked around, and left the cans where they were, hurrying back toward the fence. The footage was clear, time-stamped, and continuous. It did not require interpretation. It required only watching.
I called Deputy Marcus Bell from the kitchen phone, keeping my voice steady. "Marcus," I said. "It's Frank Delaney. The lock's been cut again, at the tank. I've got it on camera this time, and I've got cans on the ground, and I haven't touched anything."
Bell did not waste time on surprise. "Stay there," he said. "Don't move the cans or the lock. I'm on my way."
I went back outside and stood by the workshop with Buster, waiting, with the logbook open on the bench and the photographs already filed in my mind in order. The morning light was coming up over the fence now, pale and clean, and the dew was drying on the grass. I thought about the first cut lock, bagged by Bell weeks ago, and about Scott Pruitt denying everything when Bell questioned him, and about the tow truck, and the fines, and the minutes Lois had brought me, and Paul Wendell's statement. Each of those had been a single fact, standing alone. Now they were standing together.
When Bell's cruiser turned into the driveway, its tires crunching on the gravel, I felt something shift in the morning. It was not relief, exactly. It was the recognition of a pattern becoming undeniable: the same man, the same tank, the same kind of cut, the second time, on camera, with cans left behind. Bell got out of the car with his kit in his hand, looked at the tank, looked at me, and nodded, the way a deputy nods when he already knows what he is about to find and is ready to write it down properly.
"Show me," he said.
I did.
Deputy Marcus Bell came on a Tuesday morning with a paper evidence bag and a pair of gloves, and he did not hurry. That was the first thing I noticed. The first time he had come out, everything had felt like a complaint. This time it felt like a case, and the difference was in the pace. He took his time.