Nathan thanked her and told her he would follow it up, and that he did not yet have the box. That last part mattered, and he said it plainly so Diane would not think the matter was settled. A lead was not evidence. A memory of a remark was not a document. But it was a direction, and it pointed toward Finch, who was still living in the neighborhood and who might still have the box, or might remember what he had put in it. Nathan left the coffee shop with a note in his book and a name circled: Harold Finch, outgoing president, handover box, verify the enforcement papers.
He called Reyes from the car and told her what Diane had said, with the same care Diane had used: what was certain, what was not, and what still needed to be found. Reyes said she would arrange a conversation with Finch, and that they would ask him about the box before they asked him about anything else. Nathan agreed. If Finch had warned Pamela, that was a fact the inquiry needed. If he had not, they needed to know that too. Either way, the answer would come from Finch and from the box itself, not from anyone's argument about what Pamela must have known. Nathan drove back to the station with the notebook on the passenger seat, and he did not hurry. The case was moving now on paper and on testimony, and that was the pace it was supposed to move at.
On the drive back to the station, Nathan thought about how to approach Finch. An outgoing president who had handed over a box and offered a warning would not necessarily welcome a police inquiry, especially one that might embarrass his successor. Nathan decided he would not arrive with conclusions. He would arrive with a question about a box, and he would let Finch answer it in his own time. Reyes agreed when he called her, and she said she would make the first contact herself, formally, so that Finch understood this was part of a documented inquiry and not a casual conversation on a doorstep. That formality mattered. If Finch produced the box, its contents would need to be preserved exactly as he had kept them, and any statement he gave would need to be recorded properly. Nathan filed Diane's account in the inquiry folder that afternoon, marking clearly which parts were her certain memory and which were her best recollection. The distinction, he knew, would matter later, when someone tried to blur it.
Pamela returned to the curb in front of 118 Willow Bend on a Thursday morning, while Evan's van sat in its usual place and Nathan was finishing a routine patrol of the sector. She flagged him down as he drove past, and she told him she had something new to report. She said she smelled something chemical near the van. She said it the way a person says something they have rehearsed, with the emphasis on the word chemical, and she asked Nathan to run the dog around the vehicle now, while the odor was still present.
Nathan got out of the SUV and stood on the sidewalk, and he asked her to state exactly what she smelled, when she had smelled it, and from where. He asked it the way he asked every witness who reported an odor, because an odor report was only useful if it could be tied to a place and a time. Pamela said she had smelled it that morning, near the van. Nathan asked where she had been standing. She said she had been walking past on the sidewalk. He asked how close she had come to the van. She said close enough. He asked whether she had stopped beside it, or leaned toward it, or stood at the curb. She said she had walked past, and that the smell had been strong enough to notice from the sidewalk.
Nathan asked what the chemical smelled like. Pamela hesitated. She said it smelled chemical, like solvents or something from a workshop. Nathan asked whether she could name the substance, or describe it more precisely than chemical. She said she could not, but that it was definitely chemical. He asked whether anyone else had smelled it. She said no, she had been alone. He asked whether she had smelled it on any other morning, or only this one. She said only this morning, and then she corrected herself and said she had noticed something similar before, but not as strong. Nathan wrote each answer down as she gave it, and the answers did not get stronger as they accumulated. They got thinner.