HOA Karen Dug 3 Trenches Across My Road — Then a $2.6M Utility Claim Landed Hard on Her HOA

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second letter arrived two weeks later. This one was a violation notice, not a courtesy. The complaint was my truck. The muddy 2008 Ford F-150, parked at various times on Bailey Lane, was described as a "commercial-appearing vehicle" that detracted from the entrance presentation, again in violation of the CC&Rs. It gave me ten days to remove it or screen it from view.

I wrote back again, with the same facts, the same survey copy, and a sentence noting that the truck was my personal vehicle, parked on my own land, and that the CC&Rs did not apply. I filed both letters.

The third letter complained about the fence line. I did not have much of a fence line — a few old posts and wire along part of the lane, put up years earlier to keep nothing in particular out — but the letter described it as "deteriorated and inconsistent with community standards." The fourth complained about the trash cans. I kept my cans beside the shop, out of sight from the highway, but on collection day I rolled them to the end of the lane, and the letter said they were visible from the boulevard for an "unreasonable period." The fifth complained about the lawn. I did not have a lawn in the Cedar Ridge sense; I had grass, and moss, and ferns, and ground that had never been sodded, and the letter called it "unmaintained turf."

Each letter cited the CC&Rs. Each letter gave a deadline. Each letter was signed by Brielle Edwards. I answered each one in writing, calmly, with the survey and the deed, and I filed each reply in the box. The box was getting fuller, which I took as a sign that the system was working, in the sense that paper was being answered with paper.

I did not shout. I did not call her. I did not drive over to the boulevard and make a scene. I had learned, in my years of renting, that volume rarely wins an argument with an institution. Paper does. Paper sits still and waits, and when the time comes, it says exactly what it said on the day it was written. That was my strategy, insofar as I had one: keep the paper straight, keep my temper straighter, and let the facts do the work.

It was, I thought, a reasonable strategy. It assumed the other side would eventually read the paper.

The sixth letter complained about the paint color of the cabin.

I read that one standing in the kitchen, coffee in hand, and I had to sit down. The cabin was a small two-bedroom structure with a metal roof and wood siding that I had painted a muted green years earlier, a color chosen to disappear into the firs rather than announce itself. The letter described it as "non-conforming exterior color, visible from Cedar Ridge common areas," and cited a CC&R section on approved palettes. It gave me thirty days to repaint in an approved color, and it enclosed a list of approved colors, all of them in shades of beige, gray, and something called "warm stone."

My cabin was a quarter mile back from the highway, behind trees, behind the landscaped strip, behind the boulevard. It was not visible from Cedar Ridge common areas in any meaningful sense, unless you stood on the boulevard with binoculars and looked very hard through the firs. But visibility, I was learning, was not the point. The point was the letter. The point was the list. The point was that a volunteer board with a quarterly newsletter had convinced itself that its jurisdiction extended as far as its gaze.

I wrote back, as I always did. I enclosed the survey again. I noted, politely, that the cabin was on my parcel, not in Cedar Ridge, and that its paint color was not subject to Cedar Ridge approval. I filed the reply, and I put the approved-color list in the box too, because it seemed like the kind of document that might matter later, if only as evidence of how far the thing had gone.

By then the file box had a rhythm to it. A letter would arrive, usually on a weekday, in the heavy HOA envelope. I would read it, make a copy of my reply, and file both together, with the date written on the top in pencil. The box sat on a shelf in the shop, beside the tractor manuals and a tin of spare bolts, and it grew heavier by the week. I did not think of it as a case. I thought of it as a record. Records are useful when memories differ, and memories, I suspected, were about to differ a great deal.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Dug 3 Trenches Across My Road — Then a $2.6M Utility Claim Landed Hard on Her HOA

45 Part