Depositions are not trials. Alice explained that to me before mine, and she explained it again before Brielle's, because she wanted me to understand what I was walking into. A deposition is a room, a table, a court reporter, and a long series of questions under oath, with lawyers present and no judge to interrupt. It is slower than a trial and, in some ways, more revealing, because there is nowhere to hide behind a speech. You answer the question, or you refuse and explain why, and the transcript remembers either way.
Brielle's deposition took a full day. I was not in the room for most of it — Alice advised me to stay out, and I was glad to take the advice — but I read the transcript afterward, in Alice's office, with a pencil in my hand and the file box on the floor beside me. Reading it was like reading one of her newsletters, except that this time someone was asking follow-up questions.
Her story, under oath, was the story she had always told. The work was HOA drainage work. It was approved. The strip was part of the entrance area, or effectively so, and the HOA had a responsibility to maintain the entrance. She had hired Brennan to improve drainage along the verge, and the trenches were part of that work. She spoke confidently, the way she had always spoken, and for the first few pages the transcript reads like a board meeting.
Then the questions narrowed, and the documents came out. The carrier's lawyer asked about the approval. Which meeting? Which vote? Which minutes? Brielle said the board had approved it, but she could not point to a date. She said the approval was understood, that the board had discussed drainage generally, that she had authority as president to act on maintenance. The lawyer asked whether she had a written authorization. She said she did not have one with her. He asked whether one existed. She said she believed the board supported the work.
Then came the cash receipt. Brennan had written it himself that morning: cash paid for excavation work on Bailey Lane, not on the HOA's verge, not described as drainage maintenance, but as trenching across the lane. The lawyer read it aloud and asked whether it was accurate. She said she did not remember the exact wording. He asked whether she had paid cash. She said she had paid for the work. He asked why cash, rather than a check from the HOA account. She said it was faster.
Then came my photographs. The lawyer showed her the trenches, one by one. Three cuts, across the full width of the road, at intervals along the strip. Not a drainage swale along the verge. Not a shallow channel beside the boulevard. Trenches across the only road to my house. She said the photographs showed the work and did not dispute where the trenches were. She could not. They were dated, and the dates matched the morning Brennan was there.
Then came the plat. The lawyer spread it on the table, and the transcript notes a pause. He asked her to point to the HOA's property. She pointed to the boulevard and the lots. He asked her to point to Bailey Lane. She pointed to the strip. He asked her who owned it. The transcript records a longer pause, and then her answer: that she had understood it to be part of the entrance area. The lawyer asked whether she had ever seen a deed or a survey showing that. She said she had not looked at one. He asked whether she had ever asked Dobby Bailey for permission. She said she had not, because she had not believed she needed it.
I closed the transcript and sat for a while in Alice's office. Brielle's story had not survived contact with the receipt, the photographs, and the plat. It had not been shouted down. It had been documented down, one exhibit at a time. That felt consistent with everything I had learned about this dispute. Paper beats volume, even under oath, and especially under oath.