HOA Karen Dug 3 Trenches Across My Road — Then a $2.6M Utility Claim Landed Hard on Her HOA

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The letters kept coming, and they kept citing the same CC&Rs, as if repetition would make them apply. Dust again, in a new letter with a new reference number. The truck again, this time with a photograph attached — my F-150, taken from the boulevard, mud and all, as if the mud were an offense in itself. The fence again. The cans again. Each one gave a deadline. Each one was signed by Brielle Edwards. Each one, I noticed, was a little less "courtesy" and a little more "violation" than the last, as if the tone were being turned up by degrees.

I answered them all. I did not miss one. I did not let a deadline pass without a reply, because a missed deadline is the kind of thing that gets written down and quoted back at you. My replies were short, factual, and identical in their core: not a member, not HOA property, here is the survey, here is the deed. I did not vary the message, because the message did not vary. The land did not change because a letter arrived. The deed did not change because a photograph was taken. The facts were the facts, and I intended to keep stating them until someone on the other side read them.

In the evenings, I would sit on the porch and listen to the quiet, and I would think about how strange it was that a road I had driven for years without incident had become a correspondence. The lane had not changed. The cabin had not changed. The only thing that had changed was that someone with a clipboard had decided it was a problem, and now the problem arrived in envelopes.

I was still not worried, exactly. I was watchful. There is a difference. Worry is what you feel when you do not know what will happen. Watchfulness is what you feel when you know the shape of what is happening, and you are waiting to see how far it goes. I was watchful, and the file box was my way of staying watchful without losing sleep.

The fines began in the autumn.

The first fine notice arrived with a violation letter about dust, and it was for fifty dollars. It stated that I had failed to abate the dust condition within the time given, and that a fine of $50 had been assessed against my "account." I did not have an account with Cedar Ridge. I had never opened one, never been billed by them, never agreed to be billed by them. But the notice had an account number on it, printed neatly, as if the number itself created the obligation.

I wrote back, with the survey and the deed, and I noted that no fine could be assessed against a non-member for land that was not HOA property. I filed the notice and my reply, and I did not pay the fifty dollars.

The second fine was for $100. It cited the truck, and the fence, and a failure to comply with "multiple outstanding violations." The amount had doubled, which I took to be the escalation ladder working as designed: first a small fine, to see if you would pay it to make the letters stop, then a larger one, to see if the larger amount would do what the smaller one had not. I did not pay that one either. I wrote back, with the same facts, and I filed it.

The third fine was for $250. It arrived with a letter that used the word "continued" several times, and it listed dust, truck, fence, trash cans, lawn, and paint color together, as if the accumulation of complaints made them more valid. The total, if you added the fines together, was four hundred dollars, plus whatever the letters called "administrative costs." I did not add them together in my reply. I simply stated, again, that I was not a member, that Bailey Lane was my fee-simple land, and that the fines had no basis.

I want to be fair to Brielle here, because fairness matters when you are telling a story about someone who later did something indefensible. She was not sloppy. The fines were not random. They followed a pattern, they were documented, they cited sections, they gave deadlines, they kept copies. That is what made her formidable. A disorganized person with a grievance is an annoyance. An organized person with a grievance is a system. Brielle had built a system, and the system was now producing fines on a schedule, each one neater than the last.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Dug 3 Trenches Across My Road — Then a $2.6M Utility Claim Landed Hard on Her HOA

45 Part