HOA Karen Sent Her Son With a Baseball Bat to Drive a Black Homeowner Out — Then His FBI Badge Hit the Pool Deck

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Mr. Torres? This is Detective Rachel Kim, Crestwood Lakes Police Department. I'm the lead investigator on yesterday's incident at the pool. Do you have twenty minutes this morning?"

She does not sound rushed. She does not sound impressed, either. Her voice is even, unhurried, the voice of someone who has already read Officer Daniel Brooks's report twice and has questions she intends to ask in her own order.

"I do," I say.

"Good. I'm at the station. I'd rather talk to you here than at your house. Less audience."

I understand what she means. In Crestwood Lakes, a police car outside a house becomes a story before the officer has turned off the engine.

Elena comes into the kitchen while I am getting dressed. "Is that about yesterday?" she asks.

"Detective Kim. She wants a statement."

"Are you all right? Really?"

"I'm all right," I say. "I'm just tired of being careful in my own neighbourhood." I kiss the top of her head and go.

Detective Kim meets me in the lobby of the police station. She is forty-four, her dark hair pulled back, a notebook already in her hand. She shakes my hand once and leads me to a small interview room.

"Thank you for coming in," she says, sitting down across from me. "I know you've already spoken to Officer Brooks. I'm going to ask you some of the same questions again. That's normal. Memory doesn't change, but the way people tell it the second time sometimes does."

She opens the notebook. She does not ask about my job first. She asks about the pool. What time did I arrive? Where did I sit? Where was my towel? Where were my keys? Who was there when I got there? Who arrived after me?

I answer each question the way I answered Brooks. I arrived a little after four. I put my towel on a chair near the shallow end. My keys were beside it. Mrs. Lucia Alvarez was already there, by the shallow end. The five homeowners — Walter Kline, June Park, Henry Moss, Bethany Cole, Samir Patel — were around the pool, some in the water, some on the loungers. Children were playing. It was an ordinary late afternoon.

"And Evan Sutton?" Kim asks.

"He came through the gate with the bat already in his hand."

"Did he say anything before he raised it?"

I tell her what he said. My mother told you what would happen if you kept causing problems. Pack your stuff. Sell the house. Get out of this neighborhood. You think because you bought one house here, you belong? My mother runs this place. She told you to stop fighting her.

Kim writes it down without looking up. Her pen moves steadily, no pause, no reaction.

"Did you move toward him?" she asks.

"No. I stepped away from the families near the pool. Away from the water. I didn't want anyone behind me."

"Did you identify yourself as FBI at any point before the wallet fell?"

"No."

"Did you draw a weapon?"

"I didn't have one on me. I was at the pool."

She nods. She asks about the table, the second strike, the wallet sliding across the wet deck, the badge catching the sun. She asks what Evan said after he saw it. I tell her. He whispered, "Oh." Then I told him to put the bat on the ground, and he did.

Kim closes her notebook for a moment and looks at me directly for the first time since we sat down.

"Mr. Torres," she says, "I'm going to be straight with you. I don't care what your badge says. I don't care what your title is. I care about what happened on that deck, in what order, and who saw it. Titles don't make a witness more reliable. They just make people assume he is. I'm not going to assume anything."

"Good," I say. "Don't."

She almost smiles. Not quite. "I've already pulled the clubhouse camera footage," she says. "I'm going to watch it frame by frame before I talk to anyone else. If your account matches the camera, that's one thing. If it doesn't, we'll talk again."

"That's fair," I say.

She stands, and I stand with her. "One more thing," she says at the door. "Stay out of it. Don't talk to Evan. Don't talk to Diane. Don't talk to the witnesses about what they saw. Let me do my job."

"I will," I say, and I mean it. I have spent my career telling other people to stay out of their own cases.

When I get home, Maya is at the kitchen table drawing a picture of a pool. "Did the police lady believe you, Dad?" she asks.

"She's going to look at everything first," I say. "That's her job."

News in the same category

HOA Karen Sent Her Son With a Baseball Bat to Drive a Black Homeowner Out — Then His FBI Badge Hit the Pool Deck

45 Part