June Park goes next. She is forty-one, and one of the three people who screamed. She screamed because the bat hit the table so hard she thought it would shatter, and because there were children in the water. She saw Michael put his hands up, palms out, and step back. She saw the wallet slide across the wet deck and the badge catch the sun. Then Evan put the bat down.
Henry Moss is fifty-five. He was in the water with Samir Patel when Evan arrived. He got out when he heard the first strike, to be between Evan and the children. Michael was already doing that, stepping away from the pool, drawing Evan away from the families. Henry has lived here twelve years and has never seen Michael raise his voice to anyone.
Bethany Cole is thirty-six, and the second person who screamed. She was talking to June near the steps when Evan came in. She grabbed her daughter's arm and pulled her back. Michael told Evan to put the bat down, calmly, twice, and Evan listened the second time, after the badge was visible.
Samir Patel is forty-seven, and the third person who screamed. He was in the water when the bat hit the table. He saw Mrs. Lucia Alvarez freeze beside the shallow end, and Michael step sideways, away from her and the children. When Officer Brooks arrived, Michael was the calmest person at the pool.
Five statements. Five different voices. Five different vantage points — a lounger, the steps, the water, the shallow end. And they align. Not word for word, but point by point: Evan arrived with the bat. Michael was by the chairs. The bat struck the table twice. Three people screamed. Michael stepped away from the families. The wallet fell on the second strike. The badge was revealed by accident. Evan put the bat down.
Kim tells me this, carefully, without quoting them directly. "They align," she says. "That's rare. Usually witnesses disagree about the small things. These five disagree about nothing that matters. They were all watching. They all saw the same thing."
Later that week, Walter Kline stops me at the mailbox. "Mr. Torres," he says, "I told Detective Kim what I saw. I was a teacher for forty years. I know what it looks like when a young man is frightened and trying to be brave, and I know what it looks like when a man is trying not to frighten anyone else. You were the second one. Evan was the first. I told her that."
"Thank you, Walter," I say.
He nods and walks on. I stand at the mailbox thinking about what it costs to be a witness when the person you are testifying about is the mother of the young man who threatened your neighbour, and the president of the board. It costs something. Walter paid it. June paid it. Henry, Bethany, and Samir paid it. Because they did, the truth at the pool is no longer just my word against Diane's. It is five words, and a camera, and a recording, all saying the same thing.
Nicole Grant is twenty-six, Evan's girlfriend, and she is the last person Detective Kim interviews in this part of the investigation. I have seen Nicole before, at the pool and at the grocery store, walking with Evan, laughing at something he said. I have never spoken to her.
Kim tells me afterward that Nicole came to the station on her own. She called Kim, not the other way around. She said she had something to tell her, and she wanted to tell it before anyone else told it for her.
Kim meets her in the same small room. Nicole sits down, folds her hands in her lap, and asks if she can start at the beginning. Kim says yes, and listens without interrupting, the way she listened to Diane, the way she listened to me.
Nicole tells Kim what Evan told her that morning.
That morning, Evan woke up early, before Nicole did. He was already dressed when she came into the kitchen. He was pacing. He was breathing too fast, the way he breathes when he is nervous. He told her his mother had called him the night before, and again that morning, and that she was upset. He told her his mother said Michael Torres had threatened her, had disrespected her, had made her afraid in her own neighbourhood. He told her his mother said someone needed to make Michael understand that he did not belong here, and that Evan, as her son, was the one who had to do it.