Kim said the second recording added three things the first one could not prove on its own. First, it proved that I never moved toward Evan. From the front, it had looked as if we were standing close together. From the side, the gap was clear: I was near the chairs, he was near the table, and the families were between us until I stepped away from them. Second, it proved that Evan had time to stop. The recording showed him pausing after the first strike, looking at the people who had screamed, holding the bat down at his side for a few seconds before he raised it again. Third, it proved that the badge had not been flashed or shown. It had been knocked off a chair. No one had held it up. No one had waved it. It had fallen, opened, and slid, and the sun had done the rest.
I watched the second recording once, with Kim, on a small monitor in her office. I did not want to watch it twice. Once was enough to see what the neighbours had seen: a man with a bat, a man without one, and a pool full of people who had come to swim on a late afternoon and found themselves watching something they would remember for a long time.
What stayed with me was not only what the second camera showed, but what it did not show. It did not show me reaching for anything. It did not show me raising my voice or stepping forward. It showed a man standing by his chair, with his towel and his keys beside him, trying to keep the space between himself and a bat as wide as he could, while the people around the pool did what frightened people do: they moved toward their children, they covered their mouths, they waited for someone to make it stop. That was the whole scene, from the side as well as from the front, and no second telling of it could make it look like something else.
Kim put the recording in evidence with the first one, and with the 911 call, and with the messages. "One camera can be argued with," she said. "Two cameras, from two angles, at the same time, with the same time stamp — that is harder to argue with. And when you add the messages, and the timeline, and Evan's own words, there is not much left to argue."
She was right. The second recording did not tell a new story. It told the same story, more clearly, from a place where no one could say the camera had missed something. Mrs. Alvarez had been standing right there, beside the shallow end, and the second camera had been standing with her.
Diane Sutton ran the Crestwood Lakes board alone for six years. That is not my opinion. That is what Tom Becker told Detective Kim, and what Sofia Ramirez confirmed in her minutes, and what the other board members admitted, one by one, when Kim asked them how decisions were made.
The board had five members. On paper, they met once a month. On paper, they voted. On paper, the president was first among equals. In practice, Diane set the agenda, wrote the minutes before the meeting, and told the other members what they were going to approve. Tom Becker, the treasurer, told Kim he had stopped bringing questions to meetings after the first year, because Diane would answer them before he finished asking, and her answer was always the same: she had already handled it.
Sofia Ramirez kept the minutes. She told Kim she kept two kinds: the ones Diane approved, which were short and clean, and her own notes, which were longer and messier, written in a notebook she kept at home. In her own notes, Sofia had written down the times Diane had fined a homeowner without a vote, the times she had sent a letter without telling the board, the times she had told a neighbour that "the board" had decided something the board had never discussed. Sofia had kept those notes for years, because she was afraid, and because she did not know who to show them to.
The vote that wasn't — that was what Becker called it, when Kim asked him about my violation letters. "There was no vote," he said. "Diane decided. She wrote the letter. She signed it as the board. The rest of us found out when the homeowner called to ask why they had been fined." Becker said he had signed the letters after the fact, when Diane put them in front of him, because he did not want a fight, and because he told himself the letters were probably justified. He said he was ashamed of that now. He said he had been afraid of Diane for years, and that fear had been easier than a fight.