The search was executed in the daytime, by county officers Ellison did not know personally, with Hadley's counsel notified in advance as the authorization required. No one broke in. No one went through bedrooms or personal papers beyond the scope of the authorization. In the home office, in a drawer with other neighborhood paper, the officers found what Ellison had hoped to find and what Hadley had not destroyed: a copy of the directory update sheet, with Sterling's signature on it, in his steady hand, alongside the names of other neighbors. There was also, in the same drawer, a folder of neighborhood correspondence and a legal pad with practiced signatures on it. The officers photographed each item in place, bagged each one separately, and logged each one before they left.
Ellison received the sheet that afternoon, in a sealed bag, and she did not open it at her desk to admire it. She logged it, assigned it an item number, and sent a copy — not the original — to the state laboratory for examination, with a request that the original be preserved untouched. She wrote in her file, in her own hand: "Directory sheet recovered through lawful process. Home-office copy. Original preserved. Copy to lab."
Sterling was not present for any of this, and he did not ask to be. He learned, again through a brief letter, only that a document had been recovered and sent for examination. He did not ask what document. He understood the rule that had been set on the first day: victim and witness only. He went on answering his mail, keeping his garage door closed when he was finished working, and driving nowhere in particular, because there was nowhere he needed to prove anything.
Hadley, for her part, did not deny that the sheet existed. She could not, once it had been photographed in her drawer. She said, through counsel, that she had kept it as part of the neighborhood directory, which was true in the narrow sense that she had kept it. What she did not explain — what she could not yet explain — was why a directory sheet, circulated for neighbors to reach each other, had been kept in a drawer alongside a legal pad covered in practiced copies of one man's signature. That explanation would be asked for later, in a room with counsel present, and it would not be answered by a note or a smile. For now, the sheet sat in an evidence bag, and the case had its second piece of paper: one signature given freely on a porch, and one signature questioned on a bill of sale, waiting to be compared.
The officers' inventory listed each item separately: the directory sheet, the folder of neighborhood correspondence, and the legal pad, each photographed, each bagged, each initialed. Ellison checked the photographs against the bags when they arrived, the way she had checked every item in the case so far, and the count matched and the labels matched. That ordinariness was itself useful. A document found where a person keeps her own paper is harder to dismiss than a document found somewhere surprising. She added the inventory to the log and sent the copy on to the laboratory that same day.
Ellison kept the original sheet sealed and untouched, sending only the copy to the laboratory, so that no later argument could claim the comparison itself had altered the evidence.
Dr. Alan Weiss worked at the state laboratory, in a room with steady light and no distractions, which was how he preferred it. He had examined questioned documents for many years, and he approached each one the same way: without knowing, at first, what the investigators hoped he would find. Ellison sent him the bill of sale, a copy of the directory sheet, and a set of known genuine signatures from Sterling — his registration forms, his written replies to Hadley's notes, and his statement signature — each labeled and dated, each with its chain of custody noted.
Weiss began with the genuine signatures. He studied them under magnification, noting the way Sterling formed his letters when he was not thinking about forming them. A natural signature, Weiss explained later in his report, has a rhythm to it. The pen moves with a certain speed. The letters connect in places where the writer's hand is used to connecting them, and they separate in places where it is used to separating them. The pressure varies in a pattern, heavier on downstrokes, lighter on turns, because a hand that has written a name thousands of times does not press evenly. It presses the way it always has.