At the bottom of the box, under the receipts, was a smaller thing: a note in Margaret's handwriting, on a piece of paper torn from a pad, with a paint sample attached to it. The sample was dark green, almost black in the garage light. The note said, in her round, unhurried script: "This one. It will look like evening." Tate held it for a moment longer than the other papers, and then he handed it to his father.
Sterling read it without speaking. He had not seen the note in years, though he remembered the day she had chosen the color. She had stood in the garage with Tate and him on a Saturday morning, holding up samples, and she had said the car needed a color that would not shout. She had picked the dark green, and Tate had picked the black interior, and Sterling had rebuilt the engine, and they had gone on from there, year by year, until the car was finished and she was not there to see it finished. The note was not evidence in the legal sense, or not only that. It was proof of a different kind: that the car had been chosen, not bought, and that the choosing had been done by a woman who was no longer alive to explain it.
Tate did not make a speech about it. He put the note back in the box, on top of the photographs, and said only, "She picked it. You know that." Sterling nodded. They closed the box, and Tate carried it to the house, where it would wait for Ellison's office to collect it. In the garage, the Mustang sat in its half-shade, dark green almost black, chrome catching the light, and neither man said anything more about selling it, because there was nothing more to say. The paper in the box, the note in Margaret's hand, and the car itself all said the same thing, quietly, and that was enough for the morning.
Ellison's office collected the box the following Monday, and Tate walked the clerk through the inventory, photograph by photograph, receipt by receipt, until the clerk initialed each page. Sterling stayed in the garage while this happened, polishing nothing, and when Tate came back he found his father sitting on the workbench stool with his hands in his lap, looking at the car as if it had just been returned to him. It had not gone anywhere. But the record of how it had come to be his, and whose choice it carried, was now in a file where it could not be waved away.
Tate came to the garage in the evening, after the shop had closed and the light outside had gone thin. He did not knock. He never had. The side door opened on its familiar hinge, and he stood for a moment in the doorway with his hands in his pockets, looking at the Mustang the way a man looks at something he has already measured and found sound.
Sterling was at the workbench, not working. A rag lay folded beside a bottle of polish. The chrome had been cleaned that morning, and cleaned again, because there had been nothing else useful to do with his hands.
"You eat?" Tate asked.
"Enough," Sterling said.
Tate nodded and pulled the second stool out from under the bench. He sat without ceremony. For a while neither of them spoke. The garage held the particular quiet that had belonged to it since Margaret died — not empty, exactly, but careful, as if loud talk might disturb an arrangement that was still settling.
The Mustang sat in the half-light, dark green gone almost black where the overhead bulb did not reach it. The black interior was in shadow. Tate reached out, almost without thinking, and rested his palm flat on the fender, the way he had as a boy when the car was still a rusted shell and his mother had brought them out here on a Saturday morning.
Sterling watched his son's hand and said nothing. He had learned, in the years since Margaret's death, that silence between a father and a son was not always a failure to speak. Sometimes it was the only accurate thing.
"They called me at the shop," Tate said at last. "Ellison's office. They wanted the receipts again. The paint invoice. I gave them copies."
"Good."
"I also gave them Mom's note. The one about the color."