Sterling nodded. He remembered the note. Margaret had written it on the back of a paint-sample card, in her quick, slanted hand, and tucked it into the folder with the first estimates. Dark green, she had written, and then, underneath, because it looks like something that knows where it's going. Tate had kept the folder after she died. Sterling had not asked to see it again.
"She chose it," Tate said, not as an argument, but as a fact to be placed on the table between them.
"She did," Sterling said.
They sat with that. Outside, a car passed on the cul-de-sac, slow, and did not stop. Sterling thought about the eighteen months of notes slipped into his mailbox, the complaints about the garage door and the idling engine, the careful way he had answered each one in writing and filed his copy. He had believed, at the time, that paper would be enough to keep a neighbor at a distance. He had not believed anyone would invent a sale.
Tate turned on the stool to face the car fully. "Dad," he said, "are you all right?"
Sterling considered the question the way he considered all questions now, as something that deserved a true answer rather than a reassuring one. "I'm angry," he said. "Not loud angry. The other kind. The kind that files things."
Tate almost smiled. "That's worse, probably."
"Probably," Sterling said.
He stood and walked around to the driver's side. He opened the door — the hinge moved cleanly, the way it had since Tate rebuilt it — and looked in at the black interior, the wheel, the dash. He did not sit down. He put his hand on the top of the doorframe and left it there.
"Your mother brought us out here," he said, "because she thought two stubborn men needed something useful to argue about. She was right. We argued about the paint and the interior and the engine for years. We finished it after she was gone, and we didn't argue then. We just worked."
Tate was quiet.
"I'm not selling it," Sterling said. "Not for thirty-five thousand. Not for any price, while I live. That's not a position I'm taking for the case. That's just the fact of it."
"I know," Tate said. "I told Ellison the same thing, in my own words. I said Mom chose the color and you would never sell it."
Sterling nodded. He closed the door gently, so the latch caught without a slam. The sound was small and final in the garage.
They stayed a while longer. Tate spoke briefly about the shop — ordinary work, told in an ordinary voice. Sterling listened. Ordinary things, in a garage, with his son, beside a car his wife had chosen, belonged to no one else, and no paper printed in another house could change that.
When Tate left, he paused at the side door. "Lock up?" he asked.
"I will," Sterling said.
After the door closed, Sterling stood alone with the Mustang for a minute more. He did not polish anything. He did not need to. He switched off the overhead light, leaving the car in the half-shade, and went inside through the connecting door, closing it behind him with the same care.
The first version of Hadley's story arrived in the record before the examination did, and it arrived confidently.
"He signed it," she told Detective Mara Ellison in the first formal interview, sitting upright in a chair that was not her own and speaking as if the room were a porch with neighbors listening. "We had an understanding. Sterling signed the bill of sale. I don't know why he's pretending otherwise now."
Ellison wrote the words down without comment. She had interviewed enough people to know that confidence was not evidence, and that the first story a person told was often the one they had rehearsed for an audience rather than the one they could defend alone.
Sterling learned of it secondhand, as he was meant to. He was the victim and a witness, nothing more, and Ellison kept that boundary clean. Alice Moreno, his attorney, relayed the substance in a short telephone call: Hadley maintained a signature, a sale, a completed agreement. She did not produce a witness. She did not produce a payment record. She produced the paper itself, which was already in an evidence bag.
"That's stage one," Moreno said, in her even voice. "Let it stand against the examination."
The examination, when it came, did not argue. Dr. Alan Weiss at the state lab worked from photographs and originals, comparing the signature on the bill of sale with Sterling's known handwriting — his incident reports, his letters to the neighborhood, his signature on the directory sheet itself. His report was plain, and plainness was its force.