find it. The gate on the side — everybody knows about the side gate. I
looked everywhere. I looked in the bin and under the chairs and all along the
edge where the water comes out." His breath hitched then, once, and he
pressed the heels of both hands into his eyes with a fury at himself that Rafe
recognized as pure Eli, fury turned inward because inward was where he kept
everything. "It's not here. I lost Grandpa's watch at my own party and it's not
here."
Rafe crossed the deck. He did not hurry. He sat down on the concrete beside
his son in the place where the footprints ended, close enough that their
shoulders touched, and he looked out at the water the way Eli was looking at
it, at the deep end holding the sky, and he said nothing for a while, because
he had learned — eleven years of this boy, and a classroom of other people's
boys and girls besides — that the first thing out of a father's mouth at a
moment like this was usually the thing the father needed, and not the thing
the child did.
"I promised him," Eli said at last, very quietly, to the water. "That's the —
that's why. It's not just the party. I promised Grandpa." He said it the way he
said things at the cemetery, standing at the flat gray stone with his hands in
41
his pockets, talking in the ordinary voice he used for the living: reports,
mostly — school, the dog, a grade, the small news of a boy's year, delivered
to the grass and the stone as if delivery itself were the point. He had been
talking to his grandfather that way since the funeral, in the car on the way
home from visits, in his room at night, in his head where no one could hear
the arithmetic of it. "Last year wasn't a real party. Last year it was just cake
at home because he was — because it was right after. So I told him this year
I'd have a real one. All my friends. At the pool where he taught me. I told
him at the stone, Dad. I said it out loud, so it counts." A tear went down his
face then and he let it, too tired to catch it. "And then everybody came and it
was good, it was really good, and then Mr. Hale said the words and Jess had
to get everybody out of the water and we all just — left. In front of
everybody. I broke it in front of everybody."
The arithmetic of it was a child's arithmetic and it was unanswerable by
logic, which Rafe knew because he could feel the logic rising in him anyway,
useless and well-meant — the party happened, Eli, three hours of it
happened, nobody who was there will remember the ending the way you're
remembering it, your grandfather would not keep books like that. He kept all
of it behind his teeth. What Eli had lost that afternoon was not three hours at
a pool. It was a promise made out loud at a grave, to the man who had held
him up in this very water when he was four years old and terrified, who had
walked backward in the shallow end with his hands under Eli's back and
said, I've got you, I've got you, until the boy believed it and let go of the wall.
That man was in the ground at Bethany Gardens and his watch was
somewhere in a lost-and-found bin or the filter basket of a pump or the grass
of the easement, and his grandson had sat down alone inside a locked fence
at dusk to cry about a promise, apologizing for the crying.
42
Rafe put his arm around his son's shoulders. Eli leaned, all at once, the way
he had stopped doing in public that year — eleven was the year of not
leaning — and Rafe held on and looked at the water and said, "You didn't
break it, Eli. I want you to hear me say the whole of it, because I'm only
going to say it once and then we're going to go home and eat cake. You kept
your promise. You made it where he could hear it, and then you did the thing
you said you'd do — all your friends, this pool, the whole day of it. What
happened at the end of it happened to the party. It didn't happen from you.
There's a difference, and the difference matters, and your grandfather — " his
voice went somewhere he had to go and get it — "your grandfather knew the
difference better than any man I ever met. He taught you to swim in this
water. He would not want you sitting on this concrete believing you owe him
an apology for a padlock."
Eli cried then in earnest, briefly, the way quiet children cry, without theater
and without much sound, his face turned into his father's shoulder and his
hands holding onto Rafe's shirt as if Rafe were the wall of the shallow end.
Rafe let him. The light went the rest of the way down while they sat there.
Somewhere beyond the fence a sprinkler came on, and somebody's television
murmured through an open window, and the pool's underwater light — left
on a timer, indifferent to presidents and padlocks — bloomed on in the deep
end and turned the water the color of deep summer sky, and the two of them