HOA President Destroyed an 11-Year-Old's Pool Party — Then His Father Found Him Crying Beside the Pool

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

recalled: that I enforced the same rules I have enforced for nine years, against

a family that does not believe the rules apply to the size of its grief."

The money, he said, and his voice took on the weariness of a man reaching

the part of the evening he finds merely tedious, was association money in

transit. Hale Hospitality was a passthrough. Small associations did it every

day — the son's company took the bookings, handled the catering licenses,

99

the insurance riders, the deposits, the cleaning contracts, things the

association's own accounts were too rigid to handle at the speed of commerce

— and remitted to the association in settlements, annually, after expenses. If

the remittances had fallen behind the bookings, that was a failure of

settlement timing; his son had the schedules, the schedules would be

produced, and the association would be made whole to the dollar, with

interest, if the room wanted interest. What the room would not find, because

it was not there, was a dollar in any pocket it should not be in. In transit, he

said. Money in this world was always in transit somewhere. The question

was whether you trusted the road.

It was, Rafe thought, sitting very still, a magnificent piece of work. It had the

cracked basin in it, and it was true about the basin. It had the dues in it, and it

was true about the dues. It had a drowned child in it, hypothetical and

gleaming, and thirty-one guests, and his son's honest schedules, always about

to be produced. It had everything except the green book, open on the table

eleven feet from where Vernon stood, and the woman who had kept it, and

the woman down front who had counted the deposits and found the number

that is not a number. Rafe felt the room trying the frame on again, and found,

to his own quiet horror, that some part of him — the part that had paid those

dues gratefully for nine years — was trying it on too. Claire did not move.

Nadia did not move. Deanna sat with her hands on the green book's open

pages, holding it open, the way you hold a door.

George Anson leaned forward. He had not spoken, beyond procedure, all

evening; his voice, when it came, had the dry, unhurried quality of a man

reading a column of figures he has already added twice. "Mr. Hale. The chair

has two questions about the page you read. The page is dated the ninth of

May. Is that the date of its adoption?" "It is," Vernon said. "Adopted by the

100

board, May ninth, this year." "Then the chair's first question is which

meeting. The board met on the second of May and the thirtieth of May. The

secretary's minutes of both are before the chair—" he touched the minute

book, gently, the way Deanna had touched the green one, "—and neither

contains this rule, nor any motion like it, nor the word cap, in any connection

with the pool. But perhaps the secretary can assist. Mrs. Whitfield — did you

type this page?" And Deanna, in a voice that carried because the room had

gone to the bottom of its silence, said: "I did not type that page. I have never

seen that page before tonight. It is not on the association's paper, and the

minutes of May are complete as I typed them." George nodded, once. "The

chair's second question concerns the rule's third line. The cap, the page says,

implements the association's June fee schedule — the schedule setting the

penalty for excess guests at three hundred dollars per citation. Mr. Hale, the

page is dated May ninth. How does a rule adopted on May ninth implement a

schedule that did not exist until June?" Vernon looked at the page in his hand

the way a man looks at a step he has used for years, suddenly understanding

that it is not attached to anything. "The schedule was in preparation," he said.

"The page was prepared in anticipation." "Prepared," George said. "Then it

was not mailed." "It was—" "The bylaws require that a rule affecting owners

be mailed to owners before it may be enforced against them. Was this page

mailed to the owners of Cedar Hollow, Mr. Hale?" And Vernon Hale, who

had had a sentence ready for every occasion of his nine years, stood holding

his page and did not answer, and the silence lengthened past the length of

thought into the length of answer, and George, gently, like a man closing a

door for someone who cannot, said: "Let the minutes show the question was

asked."

What happened then did not happen all at once, and it was not a shout, and

Rafe, who had braced all night for a shout, was glad of the shape it took,

101

because it was a better shape than anger and it would last longer. It began

with Priya Shah. She stood up in the seventh row, holding her purse by its

strap with both hands, and said, in a voice that shook once and then steadied:

"In June of the first summer, my party was canceled for the filtration. I had

paid the association a two-hundred-fifty-dollar deposit and a hundred-dollar

rental fee, to the association, by check. I was told the refund would come by

mail. It has been three years. I called the office eleven times." She looked at

Vernon with a directness Rafe felt in his own chest. "You said the money

was in transit. President Hale, I would like to know where my refund went. I

News in the same category

HOA President Destroyed an 11-Year-Old's Pool Party — Then His Father Found Him Crying Beside the Pool

45 Part