Walter's own victim statement was short, and he wrote it in the same style he used for his own department's paperwork: plain sentences, no adjectives that did extra work, no account of feelings beyond what was necessary to establish what had happened. He stated that he owned the Camaro, that he had not offered it for sale, that he had not signed the document presented, and that no payment had been made to him. He stated that he had, on an earlier occasion, told Tyler Mercer only that Tyler could have the first conversation if Walter ever decided to sell. He signed the statement, dated it, and handed it to Price without comment. Price read it, nodded, and placed it with the report.
Before the officers left, Price gave an order in writing, on a department form: nobody touches the vehicle. He read it aloud, gave a copy to Walter and a copy to Evelyn, and explained, in neutral terms, that the Camaro would remain where it was, in Walter's garage, until the matter was resolved through the proper channels. Evelyn took the copy without argument, though her hands were no longer steady. Tyler took no copy, because no copy was offered to him, and he stood beside his mother looking at the garage door as if it had become a different kind of object while he was not watching.
Walter, once the cruisers had gone, did what he had decided to do while Price was still writing. He called his own department in Greenhaven, not to ask for assistance, but as a courtesy notification to his command: a local matter involving his personal property, a report filed by local officers, no request for involvement. He spoke to his deputy chief, gave the incident number, and stated plainly that he would not be directing, advising, or following the investigation beyond what any victim would be told. His deputy chief acknowledged the call, noted it, and said nothing that needed to be said twice. Walter hung up, and felt, for the first time that day, that he had put a boundary in the right place.
Price, before leaving, had told Walter something Walter had already anticipated, but which he was glad to hear stated plainly. Because of who Walter was, Price said, because he was a chief in a neighboring city, the case would go to county investigators. It was not a judgment on Price's ability, and Price did not present it as one. It was a recognition that appearances mattered, and that a case involving a police chief, even as a victim, should not be handled solely by officers who might be seen as colleagues. Walter agreed immediately. He did not argue, did not suggest an alternative, did not ask for a timeline. He wanted no appearance of influence, and he wanted that want to be on the record, clearly, from the beginning. He shook Price's hand, thanked Cole for her work, and went inside, leaving the Camaro exactly where Price's order said it would stay.
The referral went to the county the following morning, by the ordinary route: a report forwarded, a supervisor's signature, a case number assigned by a clerk who had no connection to anyone involved. Detective Ingrid Sorensen received it on her desk with a stack of other referrals, and she read it the way she read all of them, twice, once for the facts and once for what was missing. The facts were clear enough: a bill of sale, a denial, a vehicle that had not moved, a victim who was a police chief in another city. What was missing, she noted in the margin of her notebook, was everything that would prove or disprove the document: the title record, the DMV filing, the original forms from which a signature might have been taken. She made a list, in her own handwriting, and she began with the list.
Her first moves were procedural, and she made them in order. She pulled the VIN and title record for the Camaro, confirming what Walter had stated: the title remained in his name, no transfer had been recorded, and no lien or pending change appeared in the system. She then sent a hold request to the DMV, asking that no transfer be processed on the basis of the application Evelyn had filed, pending investigation, and she kept a copy of the request with the case file, stamped and dated. She drafted a preservation letter to the homeowners association, addressed to the board, requesting that all road-authorization petition forms, meeting minutes, and document-storage records be preserved in their current condition and made available to investigators. She did not accuse anyone in the letter. She did not need to. A preservation letter, properly written, was a fence around a set of papers, and fences, Sorensen believed, were more useful than accusations at the start of a case.