Before Tyler reached the sidewalk, Walter called after him, not loudly, and asked whether his evening shifts at the auto-parts store were still steady. Tyler turned and said they were, and that his manager had given him an extra night after he explained, in general terms, that his family was going through a court case. He had not given details, and his manager had not asked for them. Walter nodded and said that was good, that steady work counted for more than people thought when everything else was uncertain. Tyler smiled, a real smile this time, and said the store had just taken in a Camaro for a brake job, an older one, not as clean as Walter's, and the owner had talked his ear off about it for twenty minutes.
Walter laughed, briefly and genuinely. He told Tyler that Camaro owners were like that, and that it was one of the better faults a person could have. Tyler laughed too, and then he turned and walked on, his step a little lighter than it had been coming up the driveway. Walter stayed at the door until Tyler was out of sight around the bend, and then he went back to the kitchen, poured himself a glass of water, and sat down again at the table where they had talked. The house was quiet, but it was a different kind of quiet than it had been that morning: less like an empty room, more like a room after a guest has left and the conversation is still in the air.
The plea negotiation took place over two weeks, in offices rather than in courtrooms. Peter Lindqvist, Evelyn's attorney, met with the prosecutor in a conference room at the courthouse, and the conversations were, by all accounts, orderly. Lindqvist was a careful lawyer, and he did not waste his client's time pretending the evidence was weaker than it was.
The evidence was specific. Dr. Alan Weiss, the document examiner, had concluded that the signature on the bill of sale had been traced from the HOA road-authorization form — the form Evelyn had collected and held during secretary Martin Hale's six-week absence in Florida, when his sister was recovering from surgery. Nina Park, the DMV investigator, had established that Evelyn had filed the title-transfer application as Tyler's representative, with no payment and no power of attorney, and that the application had been held and then rejected. The title had never transferred. No payment had ever been made. Those were not arguments. They were records.
Lindqvist laid out the choice for Evelyn in his office, with the file open on his desk. A trial would mean Weiss on the stand, explaining the tracing, line by line. It would mean Park on the stand, explaining the application, field by field. It would mean Hale's log, showing when the form had been collected and when it had come back. It would mean Tyler, if called, telling the truth about what his mother had told him and when he had stopped believing it. Lindqvist did not threaten her with this. He described it, and he let the description do its work.
A plea, he said, would resolve the matter without a trial. It would mean admitting what the paper already showed, and accepting the consequences the court imposed. It would not erase the record, and it would not restore her position in the association, but it would end the case, and it would spare her son from testifying against her in open court. Evelyn listened. She asked questions about procedure, about timing, about what would happen at the hearing. Lindqvist answered each one.
Walter was not part of the negotiation. That was deliberate, and it was proper. He was the victim in the case, not the investigator and not the prosecutor, and he had never investigated or directed his own case. The prosecutor's office did, however, invite him to submit a victim statement for the hearing. Walter wrote one page. It was factual. It stated what had happened to his title, what the process had cost him in time and in fees, and what he asked of the court, which was that the law be applied as written. It contained no anger. He had not written it to punish Evelyn. He had written it because the court had asked for it, and because a factual record was better than silence.
Evelyn chose the plea. She told Lindqvist on a Friday afternoon, in his office, without ceremony. She said she understood what a trial would involve, and she did not want her son to be put through it, and she did not want to stand in a courtroom and hear the examiner describe, in public, exactly how her signature had been made. Lindqvist nodded and began preparing the paperwork. The hearing was set for the following week.