Walter gave one statement to Sorensen, in a county interview room, with a recorder running and no one else present. He repeated what he had told Price, in the same plain terms, and he added only the details Sorensen asked for: when he had spoken to Tyler about a first conversation, when Evelyn had asked about the car's value, and that he had not signed any bill of sale. Sorensen asked if he had anything else to add. He said he did not. He signed the statement, thanked her for her time, and left. That was the last time he discussed the case in any substantive way.
After that, he refused to discuss it further with anyone, and he refused politely, which made the refusal harder to argue with. Well-meaning neighbors stopped him in the driveway and on the street, offering sympathy, offering theories, offering to tell him what Evelyn had said at the last board meeting, and he thanked them, said the matter was with county investigators, and changed the subject to the weather or the street work or anything else that was not the case. He did not correct rumors. He did not confirm them. He did not explain why he would not talk, because explaining would have been talking.
One Greenhaven colleague, a captain Walter had known for years, called him at the office and offered, in a friendly voice, to look into it. Walter stopped him before the offer was complete. He said he appreciated it, and he meant that, but he did not want anyone in Greenhaven looking into a case that was not theirs, and he did not want a favor that would later need to be explained. The captain understood immediately, and the conversation moved on to staffing and budgets, and Walter was grateful, in a quiet way, for a colleague who did not need the boundary explained twice.
Sorensen, meanwhile, opened the HOA file request. She logged the preservation letter, confirmed receipt, and scheduled the collection of the road forms for the following week, noting in her file that the forms were now evidence, to be handled accordingly. The news reached Evelyn that same afternoon, through the association's attorney, who called her at home and told her, in careful language, that the county had requested the preservation of all petition forms and that the forms in her custody were now part of an investigation. Evelyn listened without interrupting, thanked the attorney, and hung up. She stood in her home office, looking at the filing cabinet and at the folder beneath the association minutes, and she understood, for the first time, that the papers she had kept were no longer hers to keep.
Martin Hale came home from Florida on a Tuesday, thinner than Walter remembered him and carrying a suitcase that looked as if it had been packed twice. He had spent six weeks in a spare room near Tampa, driving his sister to follow-up appointments after her surgery, sleeping badly, and answering HOA email on a phone with a cracked screen. He told Detective Sorensen all of this in the first five minutes, not because she asked, but because that was how Hale talked: in order, with dates, correcting himself when a date was wrong.
Sorensen interviewed him at the county office, not at his house. Hale sat upright, his hands flat on the table, and apologized for the condition of the records before she had asked about them.
"I kept the road file in the cabinet in my garage," he said. "Locked. I have the only key, or I did. When I left, Evelyn said she would hold the incoming forms. She said it would be simpler than me mailing the key."
He had not thought of it as handing over custody. He had thought of it as a favor between neighbors. He said that plainly, and then he winced at his own phrasing, as if hearing how it would sound in a report.
"Did you see the forms again after you returned?" Sorensen asked.
"No," Hale said. "I asked. She said the file was complete and filed. I did not check. That was my error, and I am not going to dress it up."
She took notes in a steady hand and asked him to walk through the road project from the beginning: the south entrance, the potholes, the contractor's estimate, the consent forms. Hale remembered the forms because he had designed them himself, one page each, with a line for the owner's name, address, parcel number, and signature. He remembered collecting most of them at the spring meeting. Evelyn had collected the rest door to door, including Walter's. Hale had never seen Walter's form after that.