Taya sat beside Kiri until the moon rose. Elias kept his distance, tending the horses and repairing a broken trough board. The two women had much to say that did not concern him. At one point Kiri laughed, a harsh little sound at first, and then more freely. The sound made the entire yard seem younger.
The following day brought the first serious confrontation over the water. Dugan sent a legal notice to the Mercer ranch asserting that Copper Crown controlled the north spring and all surface runoff within a tract purchased from the county. The notice demanded that Elias remove his trough from a designated access corridor and stop supplying water to anyone whose presence might interfere with construction. The language was neat, precise, and threatening without using the word threat.
Elias read it twice. His land title, signed by his father, described the well and a shared water path across the north boundary. He knew the older path was a source of disagreement, but he had never imagined that a railroad company could declare his act of filling a bucket an obstruction of commerce.
Mara took the paper from him. "I remember your father opening that gate during the winter of the long frost," she said. "People came from both sides of the ridge. Nobody asked which line they lived behind."
"That was before the county changed the records."
"Records don't change where a thirsty person stands."
They rode to Santa Luz to consult an attorney named Alma Reyes, who practiced land law from a small office above a bakery. Alma listened to Elias and then asked Nalin to speak for himself. It was a courtesy Nalin appeared to notice. Too often lawyers had treated Elias as the owner of the problem and Nalin as a witness to someone else's claim.
Alma spread the deeds and maps across her desk. She found three separate legal issues. The first was whether Copper Crown held a valid right to divert water. The second was whether the county had improperly extinguished a shared access easement. The third was whether the Tavani families possessed rights recognized by earlier agreements even if later recorders had failed to copy them. The law was untidy, and Alma refused to promise an easy victory.
"A judge may distinguish the right to draw water from the right to cross private land," she warned. "And an old custom may require proof from people who remember it. We need records and witnesses, not only a good story."
Nalin nodded. "We have people who remember."
"Then I want to hear them, and I want their accounts recorded accurately."
Alma called in a young translator who had worked with Tavani traders for years. Nalin accepted his assistance but corrected him twice when he used English words that implied ownership where the original language described responsibility. Alma wrote down the distinction. Elias watched with fascination. A courtroom could flatten a landscape as thoroughly as a survey if the language used to describe it was careless.
Before leaving, Alma examined the missing-page gap in the county copy. She asked who had handled the records on the day Elias visited. When he named Orson Pike, she went still. Pike had once worked for Copper Crown as a contract clerk before taking the county position. There was no automatic proof that he had concealed anything, but the connection warranted examination. Alma prepared a formal request for the original volume and a list of its custodians.
The case began to spread beyond the valley. Dr. Calder wrote a medical report describing illnesses associated with the loss of clean running water, careful to distinguish symptoms from proven causes. Seth's documents showed unusual changes to the company's land inventory. Kiri's statement described detention and intimidation. The missing page suggested that an agreement had been removed from public view. No single item was enough, but the combination made the question harder for officials to ignore.
The two days before Julian Pike arrived were filled with work that made the water dispute seem less like a courtroom argument and more like a problem living in every household along the creek. Families who had once collected water in a short morning walk now spent hours moving between the ranch and the eastern settlements. A woman named Lura, who cared for her father and three grandchildren, asked whether the new access route would allow a small cart to pass. The path was wide enough for a horse, Elias said, but a cart might struggle at the steepest bend. He rode out to inspect it with Taya and found the ground deeply rutted by recent traffic.