Seth Weller and Amos Greer described the company's instructions. Their accounts agreed on the practical details but differed in what they believed the superintendent intended. Seth thought Dugan wanted to prevent evidence from reaching the county; Amos believed the company sought to strengthen a future claim of abandonment. Alma did not ask the judge to choose between those motives yet. She asked that the documents be preserved and the water allowed to flow while the merits were examined.
At midday a deputy arrived with the original record book. Orson Pike came beside him, looking thinner than he had when Elias last saw him. The judge examined the damaged binding and the page that had been removed. It had been kept in a separate envelope for years. Orson acknowledged that he had withheld the page in response to threats against his family. He also admitted that he had failed to make a public note of its removal. Judge Whitcomb asked whether anyone had altered the text. Orson said he did not believe so, but he could not prove who had handled it before he took custody.
The court appointed an independent examiner to inspect the ink, paper, seals, and chain of custody. The judge refused to treat a dramatic revelation as a substitute for verification. Elias was impatient until Alma reminded him that a careful finding was less likely to be overturned. The communities had waited long enough; they could endure a few more days if the delay produced a decision that would hold.
Dugan took the stand late in the afternoon. He described the diversion as a temporary engineering necessity and the reservoir as a benefit for future traffic. When Alma asked why no downstream communities had been consulted, he said their interests had been considered through county representatives. When she asked which representatives, he named two officials who had not attended the site meeting. One had been out of town on the date in question. The other had retired three months earlier. Dugan's answers grew shorter as the discrepancies accumulated.
"Did you instruct employees to move the dam upstream after the access dispute began?" Alma asked.
"I gave engineering directions."
"Did your engineer approve that move?"
"The staff reports to me."
"That was not my question."
Dugan looked toward his attorney. The judge instructed him to answer. He admitted that the engineer had advised against the move, then insisted the company possessed authority to make business decisions. Alma placed the engineering warning beside the medical report and the water measurements. It was not merely a question of authority. It was a question of whether those decisions created foreseeable harm.
That evening the judge issued an interim order. Copper Crown was required to restore a controlled flow to the lower channel under independent engineering supervision, maintain the public route to the well, and stop any work that could damage the spring until the underlying claims were resolved. The order was not a final declaration of all rights. It was a protection against immediate harm. To the families who had been hauling water for weeks, that distinction mattered less than the possibility of hearing the creek again.
The company announced it would appeal. Dugan left the courthouse without speaking to reporters. Elias watched him pass and felt no satisfaction. The order had brought relief, but the reservoir remained, the damaged channel would need repair, and the question of who could cross the land was still unsettled. A legal victory did not carry a bucket to a sick child.
Before the judge's interim order took effect, Santa Luz experienced three days of disagreement about what the decision would mean. The newspaper published a careful account of the evidence, but the headline reduced the dispute to a contest between settlers and riders. People who had not attended the hearing repeated the headline as though it were the whole story. At the feed store, a man told Elias that the court had given his ranch away. Another claimed the railroad had been forbidden to build any track. Neither statement was true, but both traveled quickly because they offered a simple explanation for a complicated decision.
Elias asked the newspaper editor for space to correct the record. The editor, a thin woman named Beatrice Lane, agreed on the condition that he not write a speech about his own virtue. She wanted the facts of the order, the questions still unresolved, and the practical effect on people using the creek. Elias drafted a page that sounded like an engineering report. Beatrice crossed out half his technical language and asked him to explain what would happen when the first controlled flow reached the lower channel.