Hundreds of Warriors Surrounded a Cowboy—All Because He Gave a Girl Water!

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Meanwhile, Copper Crown's investors began asking questions. A report from the capital showed that the reservoir expansion cost more than the original design and that the delay could have been avoided by choosing the earlier bridge plan. The company's directors had accepted Dugan's assurances without independent review. Some investors argued that the dispute was merely an inconvenience caused by local resistance. Others asked why their money had financed a structure that engineers had warned against. The internal division gave Alma an opening to request documents that had previously been refused.

One morning a package arrived at her office containing a certified copy of a memo written by Dugan's predecessor. It recommended preserving the shared spring access because any attempt to obstruct it would invite litigation and endanger downstream users. The memo predated Elias's surveys and had been distributed to senior company officers. It established that the risks were not newly discovered. Elias read it with a mixture of relief and bitterness. He had spent months trying to make people believe that the problem could have been foreseen. Now an official paper confirmed it, but the paper had existed all along.

At the final rights hearing, Alma used the memo alongside the original shared-access agreement and the monitoring records. The judge heard testimony from Tavani families, ranchers, former company workers, and the engineers responsible for the diversion. The legal questions were complicated. Some land had been transferred validly; some records were incomplete; some rights had been acknowledged in one jurisdiction and ignored in another. The judge avoided pretending that one judgment could repair every historical wrong. Instead the decision confirmed a protected water-access corridor, required a jointly maintained channel, and established a process for reviewing future changes. Copper Crown retained its lawful railway easement but lost the authority to block the water unilaterally.

Nalin did not call the judgment victory. He called it a boundary around one source of harm. That phrase entered the local newspaper and was repeated by people who had never considered the difference. A boundary could protect, but protection had to be maintained. The court ordered oversight for several years, with representatives from the communities using the water and independent engineering review. Elias accepted a place on the technical committee only after its members agreed that the chair would rotate.

Dugan was removed from his position. Separate proceedings examined the unlawful detention of Kiri and the threats made against witnesses. He denied ordering the attack on Taya and challenged several accounts. The investigation ultimately established the role of two hired guards in the shooting, though the evidence did not support every allegation that had circulated. Elias was glad the findings were specific. Vague stories of universal guilt were easy to dismiss. Names, dates, and proved acts were harder to escape.

In the weeks leading to the formal marking of the water corridor, letters arrived at Alma Reyes's office from people whose names had never appeared in the case. A widow living near the western pass wrote that her husband had once guided cattle across the northern trail and had paid no toll for water. A former railroad employee recalled being instructed to remove an old sign pointing toward the spring. An elderly trader sent a sketch of the road as it looked before the county built its newer bridge. Each account added a fragment to the history, but Alma resisted using them indiscriminately. Some memories contradicted one another. Others described places that had changed so much the original location was hard to establish.

She asked Elias to help build a chronology. They spread the letters across a long table in the town library and sorted them by date, location, and what the writer could personally know. Taya and Kiri reviewed the place names, comparing them with the community maps. Julian Pike checked the references against the county records. The work was painstaking and sometimes frustrating. A letter that seemed decisive on its first reading could turn out to describe a different creek. A casually mentioned landmark could prove important because it appeared in three independent accounts.

One afternoon a man named Edwin Shaw came to the library carrying a wooden box. His grandfather had operated a freight wagon between Santa Luz and the eastern settlements before the railroad arrived. The box contained receipts, a travel journal, and a handful of faded photographs. One photograph showed the Mercer well with travelers gathered around it. Elias recognized his father's broad hat and a boy who might have been himself. On the other side stood several Tavani families with horses and covered wagons. The scene looked ordinary, which made it extraordinary in the context of the present dispute.

News in the same category

Hundreds of Warriors Surrounded a Cowboy—All Because He Gave a Girl Water!

45 Part