Then she ran a second model. In this one the gate stayed down. The head of water continued to rise in the western basin. The warehouses went first. Another two streets disappeared beneath the dye. The engineer warned that there were limits to what could be predicted with two-year-old measurements and a partly demolished landscape. She would be willing to say a considerable number of lives had probably been saved by opening the gate. She wouldn't venture to put a precise number on them. She also could not say whose loved ones died because it was opened at that particular time.
The gatekeeper's recorder gave a time nine minutes and forty seconds slow. Without that correction it seemed the order to open had been given while the schoolchildren were still crossing the lane. With it, the last truck was gone by then. Some adults remained and there was at least one child, Ilan, in the care of two women doing their best to make use of mismatched shoes, a child's coat and one another.
Martin gave evidence in his working clothes. He said he had failed to correct a report which distributed the moral weight of his choice among five people. One was in a hospital bed, one was across the river, one was sending off a train, one was trying to interpret six words on half a lunch bag, and one was about to be declared dead. That left very little danger of somebody having the time or ability to contradict him.
“Was your decision mistaken?” the judge asked.
“I can't say. I might have given the same order with all the information you've presented here. If Jory had been told the right door at the start, and the crown had paid for the repairs, and none of us had filled the sheds with flour, there'd have been no need to ask me to choose at all.”
Afterward Pip came to show him an elaborate figure she had drawn of a chicken wearing a crown. The artist was of the opinion that the situation might be clarified by putting the chickens in charge of the royal family and the royal family in charge of the chickens. Her father rolled the drawing carefully and put it into an envelope provided by the court.
Edmund Pike spoke last. He explained how he had composed minutes of a meeting that did not take place. He said in government work one sometimes had to turn a series of related decisions into a record which could be acted upon by people who were not in the room.
“There wasn't a room, Mr. Pike,” the judge said.
He appeared genuinely startled. He had been explaining arrangements painstakingly on that assumption for two years. Now the absence of walls around the imagined transaction seemed all at once an insuperable objection.
“No,” he said. “I gave them a room. I gave them one time and put everybody at one table. It would have taken quite some doing to write down a proper description of the business. We were quite busy. I thought I was gathering up what was left of a working government. I didn't understand I was getting rid of the people who had actually done the work.”
“Do you understand it now?”
He looked toward the front where a widow was holding a clock key and a girl had her mother's shoes in a bag under her chair. “Yes. I think that is going to be fairly difficult to forget.”
An Evening in the Dark
The public rooms where Elias and I had once lived contained an unreasonably large number of lamps. There were lamps for reading, lamps for looking at pictures, lamps arranged to send a gracious light across the floor in the unlikely event that a visitor had even the faintest interest in seeing where he would be putting his feet. At eleven o'clock on the night the inquiry adjourned an overloaded circuit extinguished the entire lot of them.
I had come to collect my bag from the storeroom. The bag I had packed before going north two years ago had been found behind a collapsible screen during a search for emergency bedding. Livia wished to send its contents to the clean laundry. I had prevailed on her to let me look first. There was a violet nightdress, a tiny book of star charts, a silk blouse with a tear in one shoulder and some good boots. At the bottom was a sheet torn from the calendar. A train to the mountain school was circled in green.