I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Move back," he said softly.

"Barnum's got a shotgun," Samuel warned. "He keeps it behind the pickled eggs."

"Barnum can go to hell," Vance said. He took a short iron crowbar from his belt—the kind used by miners to clear drill-holes—and wedged it under the frame of the iron grate.

Chapter III: What the Roots Dragged Down

The wood was rotten from twenty years of grease and rain, but the hemlock joists were hard as iron-wood. Vance didn't make a sound as he worked. Every time he pulled on the bar, his muscles bunching under his grease-stained coat like thick ropes, he breathed out through his nose with a wet whistle.

CRACK.

The bottom frame gave way, spitting rusty nails into the burdock weeds. Vance reached in with his bare hands— hands that were tore up by thorns and horse-bites—and cleared away the sharp splinters of pine until the hole was wide enough for a grown man’s shoulders.

"Stay behind me," he rasped, taking the bacon-fat lamp in his left hand and his iron bar in his right.

We didn't stay behind. We followed him like two rats following a stoat. The smell under the floor was different now. The warm, oily smell of the saloon was gone, replaced by a draft that blew up from somewhere deeper—a dark, cold smell like an unslaked lime-pit or a cellar where the apples have turned to grey jelly.

The saloon didn't sit on flat ground. It was built against the side of the shale ridge, resting on locust-wood posts at the front and raw mountain granite at the back. As Vance crawled deeper, the ceiling dropped until even Samuel and I had to drag ourselves on our bellies.

"Here," Samuel whispered, touching Vance's boot. "The dirt is soft here."

Vance stopped. He held the tin lamp low.

The dirt beneath the main room of the Lucky Horseshoe was supposed to be red clay and broken river shale. But here, six feet behind the main chimney stack, the ground was grey and dry as ash. It was packed down in some places, but directly beneath the floorboard where Barnum kept the heavy safe, the soil was loose, mixed with bits of white lime and crushed pine-bark.

Vance dropped his bar and began to dig with his fingers.

He didn't dig like a man looking for gold; he dug like a dog pulling a rabbit from a hole. The grey dust rose in a cloud, coating his dark face until he looked like a ghost made of flour. Samuel and I sat back against a hemlock post, watching the little circle of light from the grease-lamp flicker against the low joists above us.

Five inches down, his fingernails struck something hard. Not stone. Stone doesn't make a dry thump when iron hits it.

Vance stopped. His breath hitched in his throat.

He cleared the dust with the side of his hand.

It was a shoe. A small, square-toed shoe made of cheap red leather, held together with yellow brass rivets. The leather was dried out, cracked like a dead leaf, but the brass rivets were clean.

Beside the shoe was another one. And then a small bone, thin as a willow switch, bleached the pale yellow of old tallow.

"Abigail," Vance whispered. His voice didn't sound like a man's voice anymore; it sounded like the wind squeezing through a keyhole in an empty house.

"That ain't her," Samuel said softly.

Vance turned his face toward us, his grease-lamp throwing wild, long shadows across his skull. "What did you say, boy?"

"That shoe belonged to the Miller girl," Samuel said, his voice flat, without any fear or any sweetness. "The one who went into the woods three winters back to look for her calf. The one with the red coat."

Vance stared at the shoe. He reached down and picked it up. Inside the leather heel, carved with a small pocket-knife, were two initials: M.M.

Martha Miller. Old man Miller’s youngest. The girl the town said had been eaten by wolves up on the north bench.

"She's here," Samuel said, pointing his thin grey finger into the shadow beyond the lamp's light. "And the little boy from the livery. And the girl from the gunsmith's. They're all down here, Mr. Vance. They've been down here since before the saloon had a roof."

Vance stood—or tried to stand—his broad shoulders slamming against the heavy floorboards above. The entire floor of the Lucky Horseshoe creaked, and from the barroom above came the sudden clink of a bottle hitting a glass.

"Who's down there?" a voice boomed from above. It was Barnum. His heavy, wet footsteps moved across the boards directly over our heads. "Who's under the floor?"

News in the same category

I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

7 Part