I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They gathered in front of the Lucky Horseshoe.

The front doors didn't open. Instead, the small cellar access door—the one at the side of the building where the ice-blocks were slid down in winter— split apart with a heavy CRACK.

First came Samuel and me.

We were covered from head to foot in grey lime dust and old bone-ash. My white lock of hair was stained red with Barnum’s blood where I had brushed against his arm. Samuel was carrying the pewter doll with the blue eye. I was carrying Martha Miller’s small red shoe.

Behind us came Barnum, crawling on his knees and his one good hand, dragging his right arm behind him like a dead dog. He was crying—not like a grown man, but like a fat, terrified baby that has been left in the dark.

And behind Barnum walked Thomas Vance.

In his left arm, he carried the bundle wrapped in his grey wool coat. In his right hand, he held the sawed-off ten-gauge shotgun, its hammers cocked back with two sharp clicks that heard clear across the frozen square.

"What is this?" Marshal Hamer shouted, raising his Colt revolver. "Vance! What are you doing with Barnum?"

Vance didn't stop until he reached the mounting block in front of the church—the big block of dressed red sandstone where the women stepped down from their carriages.

He laid the bundle down on the stone.

Then he reached into his coat and threw three things onto the dirt at Old Man Miller’s feet.

First was the red shoe.

Second was a small brass pocket-knife with the initials R.C.—which belonged to Ralph Claggett, the gunsmith's eight-year-old boy who had vanished during the harvest four years back.

Third was a handful of grey earth—mixed with tiny, white ribs no larger than needle-cases.

"Look at 'em, Miller," Vance said. His voice wasn't loud, but it carried to every porch, every window, every open door in the square. "Look at your Martha's shoe."

Old man Miller dropped his oil lamp. The glass shattered on the gravel, and the yellow oil caught fire, sending a small tongue of blue flame crawling toward the red shoe.

Miller fell to his knees. He didn't pick up the shoe. He reached out his trembling, liver-spotted hand and touched the heel, where his own pocket-knife had carved the M.M. three years before.

"Where?" Miller whispered. "Where was it?"

"Under the floor," Vance said, pointing the double barrels of the shotgun at Barnum’s grease-stained forehead. "Under the floor where you drank your three-cent whiskey every night after searching the timber. Under the floor where you sat and talked about the weather while Barnum poured the drinks."

A low sound went through the crowd—a sound like the wind coming through a dry corn-field.

"He's lying!" Barnum screamed from the dirt. He tried to get to his feet, but his torn hand buckled under him, and he fell back into his own blood. "He's crazy! His girl died in the woods and he's gone mad! He dug up the old Indian grave under the ridge!"

Samuel stepped forward.

He was four years old, but he walked like an old preacher who had seen the bottom of the pit. He pointed at Claggett, the gunsmith.

"Your boy Ralph is under the third post from the door," Samuel said. "He's wearing his copper ring. The one with the green stone you gave him for his birthday."

Claggett’s face went the color of grey flannel. He dropped his gun. "My Ralph...?"

"And the girl with the blue dress," I added, stepping up beside my brother. "The one who stayed under the kitchen floor. She has her blue shoes on still. She told Sam to tell you she's sorry she dropped the milk pail."

Mrs. Claggett—a thin, pale woman who hadn't spoken a word since eighty-four— let out a shriek that tore the morning open. She didn't look at Barnum. She ran straight for the side alley of the saloon, her night-gown dragging in the horse-dirt.

"Wait!" Marshal Hamer yelled, his voice cracking like dry kindling. "Vance, put that gun down! We'll take him to the jail—we'll have a trial—"

"There ain't no jail big enough for this town, Marshal," Vance said softly.

He didn't pull the trigger. He didn't have to.

The townspeople didn't wait for the Marshal. They didn't wait for the judge who came through once every three months on the stage-coach.

Old man Miller was the first. He didn't use a pistol. He picked up a stone from the church foundation—a five-pound block of rough shale—and walked toward Barnum.

Then came Claggett. Then came the blacksmith, holding his heavy horseshoeing tongs. Then came the women, their grey aprons flapping in the morning breeze like the wings of crows.

News in the same category

I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

7 Part