I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Vance didn't answer. He laid his heavy hand over my mouth and pulled Samuel into the shadow of the chimney base. He blew out the bacon-fat lamp.

The dark was complete. It smelled of wet earth, copper, and eighty years of buried secrets.

Chapter IV: The Town Beneath the Town

Above us, a trapdoor opened.

It wasn't a trapdoor anyone in Oakhaven knew about. It was hidden behind the heavy barrel-rack where Barnum kept the forty-gallon casks of Kentucky rye. The wood screamed as it was pulled back on leather hinges that hadn't seen lard in ten years.

A lantern was lowered down through the hole. The light was yellow and greasy, swinging back and forth like a pendulum in a tall clock.

Behind the lantern came a pair of boots. Red-tinged leather, with heavy steel toe-caps.

"I hear you down there, Vance," Barnum’s voice came down the hole. It wasn't his tavern-keeper voice—the merry, greasy tone he used when he was selling three-cent whiskey to half-blind miners. It was dry, cold, and flat as a slate shingles. "I saw your horse tied to the rail behind the blacksmith's. I knew you'd come eventually. They always come when the wind turns north."

Thomas Vance didn't move. He held us against his chest. His heart was beating so hard I could feel it through his thick wool coat—a steady, heavy thump-thump-thump that felt like a iron hammer hitting a beam.

"You took my girl," Vance whispered into the dark. He wasn't talking to Barnum; he was talking to the cold dirt between his boots.

"I didn't take nobody," Barnum said from the ladder steps. He was halfway down now. His big belly overflowed his leather trousers, and his greasy grey hair hung down around his red face like lard-dipped hemp. He was holding a short-barreled shotgun—a double-barreled ten-gauge with the stock sawed down to the grip. "The town took 'em. The town needed 'em."

"You killed them," Vance said, his voice rising from a whisper to a rasping roar as he stood up, his head shoved against the floorboards.

"Oakhaven don't sit on silver, Vance," Barnum said, stepping off the last rung into the grey dust. He pointed the short shotgun at Vance's chest. The double bores looked like two wide, black well-shafts. "The silver ran out in sixty-two. You know why this town's still here? You know why the well don't go dry when the river turns to red mud from here to the Rio Grande?"

"Because you're a monster," Vance said.

Barnum laughed. It was a wet, rattling sound, like someone coughing into a bucket of lard. "Because the foundation was laid right. Old man Miller knew it. The Marshal knew it. Even the Reverend knew it when he laid the cornerstone for the church back in seventy-four. A town's like a tree, Vance. You want it to stay green when the drought comes, you got to feed the roots something that doesn't rot fast."

He gestured with the barrels of the ten-gauge toward the dark corner behind the stone chimney.

The yellow lantern light swept across the dirt floor.

It wasn't just two shoes.

The grey earth under the Lucky Horseshoe was criss-crossed with small, shallow ridges—dozens of them, laid out in neat, tight rows like the garden beds behind a parsonage. From the dry soil protruded tiny white finger bones, small brass buckles, a red ribbon tied in a knot that had held its color against the grey rot, and a row of small, grinning skulls, half-buried like turnip heads left in the frost.

There were twenty of them. Maybe thirty.

"They're the quiet ones," Barnum said softly. "The strays. The ones whose mamas were too tired to look hard, or whose daddies were too drunk to remember which side of the creek they left 'em on. Your little girl... well, she was a mistake. My boy Ned got eager up on the Red Creek road. But it didn't matter none. She's keeping the well sweet just like the rest."

Samuel looked at Barnum. He didn't hide behind Vance's coat. He walked right out into the lantern light, his bare feet leaves in the grey lime dust.

"The girl with the blue eye isn't under the safe," Samuel said. His voice was small, but it filled the crawlspace like smoke from a wet fire.

Barnum lowered the shotgun half an inch, his small, pig-like eyes squinting at the boy. "What's that rat doing out of his hole?"

"She's under the hearth," Samuel said, pointing his grey finger at the massive stone foundation of the main fireplace—three tons of granite laid in lime mortar. "She's under the big stone where you sit every night to count the register. She's still got her hair. It's long and yellow, like corn silk."

News in the same category

I Was Four When a Grieving Cowboy Followed My Twin and Me Behind a Saloon—What He Found Beneath Our Floor Made the Whole Town Beg Us for Mercy

7 Part