Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Caroline Whitmore came in last, with her lawyer, a man named Peter Alden who carried a leather briefcase and spoke in the low, smoothing voice of someone accustomed to making rooms quieter. Caroline wore a dark suit and no jewelry except a wedding band. Her face was composed. Simone watched her take the chair farthest from Simone, and thought, not unkindly, that Caroline looked like a woman who had rehearsed being calm and was discovering how much effort it took.

Pryce opened a folder and read the ground rules aloud. This was a confidential mediation, not a court. No recording. Each side would speak without interruption. The goal was a written agreement. If no agreement was reached, either side could pursue other remedies, and nothing said in the room would be used elsewhere.

"Do we understand each other?" Pryce asked.

Everyone said yes.

Sloane looked at Simone. Simone folded her hands on the table. Her hands were steady. She had expected them not to be.

"I want to start with what happened," Simone said, "because that is the only thing I can speak to with certainty. On a Saturday afternoon I went to Bellmont & Avery to buy a suit for myself and a dress for my daughter. I spent fifty-three minutes in the store. I had planned forty. I tried on three garments. I asked the fitting-room attendant for another size in one of them. I bought two garments and I paid for them at the register. A customer I did not know called the police and said I had stolen a blouse. I had not. No blouse left the store in my possession, because the blouse was behind the fitting-room counter, where the attendant had hung it, with my name on a hold slip."

She paused. The room was very quiet.

"I am a physician," she said. "I run a foundation that gives scholarships to students who are told, in various ways, that rooms like that store are not for them. I did not come here to be made an example of, and I did not come here to make one of anyone else. I came here because a false accusation followed me out of that store and into my daughter's school and into my foundation's boardroom, and it should not have been allowed to travel that far. I would like it stopped, in writing, and I would like the store to change the way it handles the next person who is accused."

She stopped. She had said what she came to say. Sloane put a hand, briefly, on the table near Simone's, not touching it, just there.

Pryce nodded. "Thank you, Dr. Bennett," she said. "Mrs. Whitmore, would you like to respond?"

Caroline looked at Alden, who nodded almost imperceptibly. "I would like to hear the evidence first," Caroline said. Her voice was even. "If that's permitted."

"It is," Pryce said. "Ms. Sloane."

Sloane opened her binder.

Chapter 29

Sloane did not raise her voice. She laid the timeline out the way Simone had first laid it out in her own memo, in the week after the incident, when the details were still sharp and before anyone else had begun to rearrange them.

"Three-oh-five," Sloane said. "Dr. Bennett enters the fitting room with three garments: a blue dress, a burgundy evening gown, and a white blouse. This is confirmed by the fitting-room log and by the camera at the fitting-room corridor."

She set a still photograph on the table, turned so everyone could see it. Simone in the corridor, holding three hangers. The image was grainy, but the count was clear.

"Three-oh-eight," Sloane said. "Dr. Bennett hands the white blouse to the fitting-room attendant, Tessa Marsh, and asks for another size. Ms. Marsh hangs the blouse behind the counter and writes a hold slip. The slip reads: white blouse β€” hold for Dr. Bennett β€” size check."

She set down a copy of the slip. Elena looked at it and then away, as if the sight of it still cost her something.

"Three-seventeen," Sloane said. "Dr. Bennett exits the fitting room with two garments. Three-thirty-five, she pays at the register. The receipt lists the black dotted suit and the blue dress. Three-forty-one, Officers Hayes and Reilly arrive, following Mrs. Whitmore's call. The blouse is produced from behind the counter, in front of Officer Hayes, where it has been the entire time."

Pryce studied each item as Sloane placed it down. Alden made notes. Caroline stared at the still of the corridor as if it might change if she looked long enough.

"Ms. Marsh's statement," Sloane said, and read it aloud.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

45 Part