Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Caroline followed and watched from twenty feet away.

She did not think of it as following. She thought of it as keeping an eye out, which sounded passive and therefore innocent. She stood near a display of scarves and pretended to consider them, while her attention stayed fixed on the fitting-room corridor. Twenty feet was close enough to see and far enough, she told herself, to be discreet.

Simone entered a fitting room. The door closed.

Five minutes passed. Caroline checked a scarf, put it down, picked up another. Ten minutes passed. The corridor filled and emptied with other shoppers, with attendants carrying garments, with the ordinary traffic of a Saturday afternoon. Caroline's patience, which had never been her strongest quality, began to fray at the edges.

Then Simone emerged, carrying only two garments.

Caroline's heart accelerated. There had been three β€” she was certain, or almost certain. She replayed the image in her mind: blue, burgundy, white. Three hangers, three shapes over an arm. Now there were two. The arithmetic felt clean and damning, and Caroline did not pause to consider the other explanations it allowed: a garment left on a hook, a garment handed to an attendant, a garment set aside for another size.

She did not go back to Anna Reyes. Anna had already dismissed her once. She went to the manager.

Elena Ruiz was behind the service desk, immediately serious when Caroline approached: not alarmed, not defensive, simply attentive.

"I believe a woman just stole something," Caroline said.

"What did you see?" Elena asked.

Caroline told her about the fitting room, about the three garments and the two, about the woman with the handbag. Elena listened without interrupting, and then asked the question that mattered.

"Did you see her conceal the garment?"

"No," Caroline said, "but she went into the fitting room with three items and came out with two."

Elena's voice stayed level. "I think you need to search her bag," Caroline said, before Elena could finish.

"We can't search customers based solely on suspicion," Elena said.

"Then call security."

"Ma'amβ€”"

"If you don't do something, I will," Caroline said. "Please don't confront another customer," Elena said, but Caroline was already pulling out her phone, her hand steady now that she had a course of action. "I'm not going to confront her," she said. "I'm calling the police."

She dialed 911.

Elena watched her, knowing that once a call like this was made, it could not be unmade by good intentions. Caroline spoke into the phone, her voice low and certain, describing a theft she had not seen. Across the second floor, Simone walked toward a register with a blue dress she believed Maya would love, unaware that a clock she had not set was already running.

Inside the fitting room, Simone had been methodical, as she was methodical everywhere. She tried the blue dress first, holding her breath a little as she turned in the mirror, and knew immediately that it was the one β€” not because it was perfect in some abstract way, but because she could see Maya in it, clearly, without having to imagine too hard. The burgundy gown was lovely and wrong, too adult, too heavy for a school formal. The white blouse fit well, but the size was not quite right across the shoulders, and Simone, who disliked returning things almost as much as she disliked ill-fitting clothes, asked Tessa Marsh, the fitting-room attendant, if another size could be located. Tessa nodded, took the blouse, and said she would check in the back. Simone thanked her, changed back into her own clothes, and gathered the blue dress and the burgundy gown, carrying those two garments out with her β€” and stepped out into the corridor, thinking about the drive home, about Maya's face, about whether she had time to stop for groceries. On her way to the register she decided against the burgundy gown after all, too adult for a school formal, and returned it to its rack, leaving her with the suit bag and the blue dress that mattered.

She did not count her garments as she left. Why would she? She had handed one to an attendant, in full view of anyone who cared to look, and she had no reason to keep a tally for a stranger twenty feet away.

Chapter 5

Simone was at the register when the officers arrived.

She had found the blue dress. That was the thought uppermost in her mind as Denise Hall, the cashier, scanned the suit and then the dress with practiced efficiency: Maya would love it. The color was right, deep and clear without being loud; the cut was simple enough for a seventeen-year-old to make her own. Simone could already see it laid out on Maya's bed, could hear the conversation that would follow β€” Maya pretending to be unimpressed, then trying it on when she thought no one was watching. It was a good thought, an ordinary, maternal thought, and Simone held on to it without knowing how soon she would need it.

News in the same category

Karen Called Police on a Woman Shopping in Her Own Boutique, Then a $680,000 Lawsuit Exposed What the Store Had Been Hiding

45 Part