"You were talking," Sarah said. She was not cruel. She was specific, and specificity, she was discovering, could feel crueler than anger if you were on the receiving end of it. "You didn't see her. None of us should have to catch someone else's toddler at the edge of a pool. This is my house, and I am responsible for what happens in this yard, and I can't be responsible for five children I didn't invite while their mother isn't watching them."
Karen's face flushed a deep, mottled red. "So this is it," she said. "This is how you treat a neighbor. You invite us—"
"I didn't invite you," Sarah said, and the sentence landed in the quiet with a finality that surprised even her. "I didn't invite you weeks ago, and I didn't invite you today. You came. And I let you stay because I didn't want a scene, and that was my mistake, because now we've had a scene anyway, and a two-year-old nearly went into the deep end."
For a second Karen looked, not angry, but stunned, as if someone had pulled a chair out from under her. Then the anger came back, bigger, to cover it. She scooped Mia out of Priya's arms with a practiced swing, gathered Emma and Lucas with her free hand, and called for Brandon and Noah in a voice that cracked on their names.
"Come on," she said to her children, not looking at Sarah. "We're leaving. Apparently we're not welcome where we're not wanted."
She herded them toward the side gate, Mia on her hip, Noah dragging his feet, Brandon filming the whole thing over his shoulder with his phone, his sneer finally gone, replaced by something embarrassed and closed. At the gate Karen turned, and the tears were there again, but this time they were furious, not pleading.
"You screamed at my babies," she said, loud enough for the street to hear, though the street was not there yet. "In front of everyone. You'll be hearing about this."
Then the gate banged shut, and the minivan doors slammed one after another, and the engine started with a cough, and they were gone, tires spitting gravel the way they had come in.
Sarah stood in the sudden quiet. The string lights hummed faintly. The pool lapped at its edges. Priya put a hand on her shoulder. Khloe stood beside her, arms crossed, chin up, daring anyone to say the wrong thing.
Dan Okafor cleared his throat. "Well," he said. "That was—" He did not finish. Rachel took his arm, gently, and steered him toward their things.
Helen Marsh said nothing at all. She looked at Sarah, and then at the empty place by the grill where Karen had been standing, and her face was a complicated map Sarah could not read yet. She picked up her bag, slowly, and said, "I'll call you tomorrow, dear," in a voice that did not commit to anything.
Sarah nodded. She did not trust her own voice to say more than that. She had said the true thing, out loud, in front of everyone, and it had cost exactly what she had feared it would cost. She stood in her own yard, among the people who remained, and felt, for the first time all afternoon, like she was standing on solid ground.
Chapter 14
After everyone left, the yard was very quiet, and very much hers again, and that should have felt like relief. Instead it felt like the moment after a storm, when you walk outside and start counting what is broken.
Khloe stayed. She did not ask. She simply did not leave when Priya left — Priya hugging Sarah hard at the gate, Maya waving sleepily from the car — and when Dan and Rachel had gone, and Helen had gone with her unreadable face, Khloe was still there, in the lounge chair, her sunglasses pushed up into her hair, a glass of water in her hand.
"You don't have to stay," Sarah said, stacking plates that did not need stacking.
"I know," Khloe said. "I'm staying anyway. Someone has to eat the leftover fruit salad, and it's clearly not going to be you, because you're about to clean this entire patio like it's a crime scene."
Sarah laughed, and then, to her surprise, felt tears come up behind the laugh, hot and unwelcome. She sat down hard on the edge of a lounge chair and put her face in her hands for exactly five seconds. Khloe did not rush her. Khloe waited, the way she had waited all afternoon, present and unflinching.
"I'm okay," Sarah said, when she could. "I'm just — my hands are still shaking. From Mia. I keep seeing her toes over the edge."