She took the best shaded seat on the patio, the one Sarah had meant for Helen, and arranged herself there with the air of a woman who had finally found her rightful place. She helped herself to lemonade, then to sparkling water, then to a plate of food, commenting appreciatively on everything as if she were reviewing it. "Oh, this is lovely," she said, to no one in particular and therefore to everyone. "Sarah, you've really outdone yourself."
Sarah watched her from the grill, tongs in hand, with a feeling she couldn't quite name. It wasn't anger, not yet. It was the strange, disorienting sensation of being a guest at her own party — of watching someone else use the things she had built as if they were public property. The cedar outdoor kitchen, which she had waited months for and sealed herself on a long night with a brush and a lamp, was now a serving station for a family she hadn't invited. The pitchers she had filled for her friends were being poured for children she didn't know. The stone patio she had designed was suddenly crowded with shoes that weren't her guests' shoes.
She tried polite avoidance. It was, after all, what she did best: smile, move, refill, keep the peace. She turned back to the grill. She checked on Maya and Ben. She asked George if he wanted more ice. She told herself that if she didn't make a scene, there wouldn't be one — that Karen would eat, the children would play, and eventually, somehow, the afternoon would right itself.
But the guests noticed. Of course they noticed. Melissa caught Sarah's eye across the patio and raised an eyebrow, a silent question: Do you want help? Sarah gave a tiny shake of her head. Not yet. Not like this. Priya, watching Emma and Lucas wander past the potted palms with the careful curiosity of explorers, leaned toward Tom and said something low that Sarah couldn't hear. Helen, who had been quietly displaced from the shaded seat, had taken another chair without complaint, but she was watching Karen with the thoughtful expression of a woman who had seen this particular play before.
Karen, meanwhile, was holding court. She told Dan and Rachel about the pharmacy, about her shifts, about how hard it was to find a decent sitter in the summer, about how the neighborhood really ought to look out for one another. She said it warmly, and she meant it — Sarah could tell she meant it, which somehow made it harder. Karen wasn't sneering. She wasn't scheming. She genuinely seemed to believe that a yard with music and food in it was, by definition, open to everyone on the street, and that Sarah's hesitation was a kind of coldness she was generously overlooking.
Karen asked Rachel about the house across the street, about the new paint color, about whether the Okafors had finally fixed their side gate, and Rachel answered politely, because Rachel was polite, and because it is very hard to be rude to someone who is smiling at you in your friend's yard. Karen asked Helen about her garden, and Helen, who loved talking about her garden, answered at length, and Karen nodded as if she had always cared about tomatoes. It was skillful, Sarah thought, in a way she almost admired: Karen could make any conversation feel like a reunion, even when she was the only one who had arrived uninvited.
"More lemonade, darling?" Karen called to Mia, who was toddling near the table with her sun hat slipping over her eyes.
Sarah opened her mouth, then closed it. The toddler wasn't hurting anything. The lemonade wasn't the point. The point was the feeling, growing quietly in her chest, that she had lost control of the afternoon without ever having raised her voice — and that if she raised it now, she would be the one who looked unreasonable.
Khloe appeared beside her at the grill, very casually, with a plate she didn't need. "You okay?" she asked, under her breath.
"I'm fine," Sarah said, automatically.
"You're doing the face," Khloe said.
"What face?"
"The face where you're being polite instead of honest," Khloe said. "It's a very specific face. I've known it since I was twelve."
Sarah almost laughed, and then didn't, because Karen was pouring herself another glass and asking Rachel if there was any more of that lovely fruit salad, and the afternoon, which had started so perfectly, was bending, slowly and unmistakably, in a direction Sarah had not chosen.
Chapter 5
By mid-afternoon, Karen's children had spread out across the yard the way children do when they sense that no one is quite in charge of them — not badly, not wildly, just everywhere at once.