Brandon had claimed a corner of the patio and was filming the pool on his phone, narrating in a low, sarcastic monotone that Sarah caught in fragments: "So this is, like, a pool party, I guess." He wasn't bothering anyone, exactly. He was simply documenting his own boredom, and occasionally glancing up to make sure someone had noticed how bored he was. Every so often he looked at his mother with the weary tolerance of a teenager who has decided that embarrassment is a permanent condition, like weather, and then he looked back at his phone.
Emma and Lucas were exploring. Emma led, as she always seemed to, talking a bright, running commentary — "What's this? Can we go here? Look at the flowers!" — while Lucas followed a step behind, quiet, picking up stones and putting them down again, examining the potted palms as if they might be hiding something. They weren't breaking anything. They were curious, and curiosity in an eight-year-old and a six-year-old looks a lot like wandering, and wandering in someone else's yard looks a lot like trespass when you haven't been invited.
Noah was testing limits. That was the kindest way Sarah could put it, and also the truest. He hovered near the pool's edge, toeing the water, backing away, daring himself. He asked Ben if he could use the pink noodle. He asked Maya if she wanted to race. He stood on the shallow-end steps and bounced, just a little, just enough to see if anyone would stop him. Ben, to his credit, ignored him with the dignity of an eight-year-old shark. Maya, less dignified, splashed him, and Noah laughed, delighted.
Emma discovered the string lights and asked, loudly, when they would turn on, and Lucas discovered a loose paver near the palms and pressed it with his foot, testing it, as if he were checking Sarah's work. Brandon, meanwhile, had moved to a new angle and was filming the cedar kitchen now, panning slowly, and Sarah wondered, with a prickle of unease, where that video would end up — not because Brandon was malicious, but because teenagers film things, and filmed things travel, and she had not agreed to be anyone's content. She said nothing. She told herself she was overreacting. She was probably overreacting. But she noticed, and noticing was becoming a habit that afternoon.
Sarah watched all of this with the divided attention of a host who is also, suddenly, a lifeguard. She kept moving — refilling pitchers, checking the grill, smiling at Helen — but part of her mind stayed on the pool, counting heads, tracking the small bodies in the water, listening for the particular pitch of a child's voice that means excitement tipping into trouble. She counted Maya, Ben, and then Noah, hovering, and then Noah again, because he kept moving. It was exhausting, this counting, and it was not the party she had planned.
Khloe ran interference the only way Khloe knew how: with jokes, deployed like a shield. When Noah drifted toward the deep end, Khloe intercepted him with a challenge to a cannonball contest that was, pointedly, not happening today. When Emma asked, for the third time, what was in the cedar kitchen's drawers, Khloe invented a dramatic story about a secret compartment that contained only napkins, and Emma laughed so hard she forgot the drawers. When Brandon filmed Khloe, Khloe posed, extravagantly, and said, "Make sure you get my good side, Spielberg," and Brandon, despite himself, almost smiled.
"You don't have to do that," Sarah said quietly, when Khloe circled back to the grill.
"Do what?" Khloe asked, innocently.
"Manage them."
"I'm not managing them," Khloe said. "I'm entertaining them. There's a difference. One of them involves applause."
Sarah smiled, grateful and guilty in equal measure. Grateful, because Khloe was buying her time. Guilty, because it was her yard, her party, and her sister shouldn't have to run interference at it. She looked across the patio, where Karen was laughing with Dan, a plate balanced on her knee, completely at ease, and she felt the question forming again, the one she kept pushing down: How long was she supposed to be polite about this? How long before politeness stopped being kindness and started being surrender?
The music played on. The ice melted in the bucket. The afternoon stretched, golden and humid, and Sarah stayed at the grill, watching the pool, waiting for the moment she knew was coming, even if she didn't yet know what shape it would take.
Chapter 6
It happened fast, the way pool accidents almost happen — not with a warning, but with a splash and a shout.