Vera interrogated the proceedings. Who was coming. Where they would stand. Whether the door would be open or closed, and if closed, whether it would be locked, and if locked, whether she would be inside it. June answered every question at the same unhurried pace, without once saying don't worry, which I had learned was a phrase Vera heard as a door closing.
Marcus arrived at noon with balloons enough for a parade and the expression of a man who had survived the party supply store and expected to be decorated for it. Marnie came with a kite she had built herself, slightly lopsided, entirely magnificent. A handful of Valerie's school friends came with their parents, vetted by Marcus with a thoroughness those parents fortunately mistook for ordinary caution.
The penthouse filled with noise — the good kind, the kind with frosting on it. The girls from Valerie's class took Vera and Violet into their games with the ruthless inclusivity of six-year-olds, for whom three identical girls in matching dresses was not a tragedy or a miracle but simply an excellent development, like a snow day.
I stood at the edge of it with a paper cup of lemonade and did the arithmetic I could not stop doing. Five birthdays. Five Aprils in a small house in Queens with the curtains drawn, a candle in a muffin, a song sung quietly — and the last one half a year from a cardboard bed.
I did not begrudge Ruth her muffin. By all the evidence she had loved them with everything she had, which was mostly just love. But love in hiding is a candle in a muffin, and my daughters were owed the sun.
"Brett." June's voice, low, beside me. "You're doing the face."
"Which face."
"The one where you're at a party and also at a graveside." She took the lemonade out of my hand and replaced it with Vera's paper crown, which I had apparently been assigned to hold. "She's over there laughing with her mouth open. Go and be where she is."
So I did. I wore the crown at an angle that Valerie immediately corrected. Marcus wore his under orders from Violet and looked, for once, like a man entirely defeated by joy. I lost a game of musical statues to Violet, who had the stillness of a child who has practiced invisibility and deployed it, to general outrage, for cake.
Then the cakes came in — three, as legislated — and the noise arranged itself around the table the way noise does when it is about to become a song.
I lit the candles myself. My hands were steady on the first cake, and the second, and on the third my hand shook once, visibly, and June's hand closed warm over mine and steadied it without a word, in front of everyone, like it was nothing, like it was the most ordinary thing in the world to hold a man's hand steady over his daughter's birthday candles.
"Make a wish," Valerie instructed her sisters, in the tone of a priestess revealing a mystery. "You close your eyes and you wish in your head. You can't say it out loud or it doesn't count."
Violet closed her eyes instantly, screwing them shut, her whole face an act of wishing.
Vera looked at the six candles on her cake for a long moment. "I don't know how," she said, quietly, and the table went soft around the edges.
"There's no wrong way," June said. "You just think of the thing you want most, and you ask the candles for it. They're very good listeners. It's their whole job."
Vera closed her eyes. She wished for a long time. Whatever it was, she asked for it thoroughly, the way she did everything, and then she opened her eyes and blew, and got five of the six, and went back grimly for the sixth while her sisters cheered like it was a cup final.
Violet, of course, announced her wish at full volume the moment her candles were out — something involving a pony, a purple bicycle, and for everyone to live in the same house forever — and Valerie wailed that it wouldn't come true now, and Violet replied, serene, "It already is the last part," and ate her frosting with her fingers.
I never learned what Vera wished for. She kept it the way she kept everything precious in those days: close, and unshared, and entirely hers.
But I know what I wished for, standing behind them with wax on my fingers and June's hand still warm in the memory of mine. It was not a complicated wish. It was only more of this — more Aprils, more noise, more ordinary mercy — for the three girls in front of me, who had finally, all three of them, been born into the same life.
All three girls started school that spring, at the school Valerie had always attended, which had seemed for five years like the outer border of a normal life.
Getting Vera and Violet there took a month of gentle engineering. There were assessments, and meetings, and a formidable headmistress who surprised me by being kinder than her reputation and tougher than mine.
The girls were behind — except that Ruth had read to them, and taught them letters at a kitchen table, and their minds, once June and the tutors began feeding them, came alight like stoves in winter.
Vera learned to read the way she did everything: by siege. Violet learned by osmosis and charm, and charmed her teachers into advancing her on potential.
Uniforms were a crisis of a new and wonderful kind. Vera objected to the shoes. Violet objected to nothing, tried on the hat six times, and slept in it once, and was found in the morning with it over her face like a tiny highwayman.