Ms. Parker told me the school had a copy of the protective order in the office now, filed under my name, and that if a certain car was ever seen in the parking lot I was to come straight to her room and sit with the door open. "You're just a student here," she said. "That's the entire job. Let us do the rest."
The call that changed the subject came from Denise's sister, on a Tuesday, and it wasn't about money or lawyers at all. My father listened a long time with his eyes on me.
"Brooke has something of Emma's," he said, when he'd hung up. "She's been asking to give it back." He let the silence sit where it belonged. "That's yours to decide, Emma. Nobody else's. Not mine, not hers. Yours."
I said yes before I understood why.
It wasn't forgiveness, and it wasn't curiosity, exactly. It was the ribbon itself — a length of faded blue silk that had been my mother's, that I'd kept in my top drawer and worn on picture days, that had vanished out of my room the week my room stopped being mine.
I'd seen it once since, in a pageant photograph on Denise's phone: in Brooke's hair, catching the light. I wanted it back in my hands. What Brooke did with the wanting was her business.
All week I rehearsed speeches in the shower and at the sink, whole courtroom speeches, and by Saturday I had worn every one of them out. In the truck I decided I would say almost nothing. Wanting the ribbon back was one true thing, and Dr. Levine had taught me that one true thing was a full day's work.
The meeting was arranged the way you'd arrange weather between countries — through the aunt, on a Saturday, on the aunt's front porch across town where Brooke was living now. My father drove me and stayed in the truck with the window down, close enough to see, far enough to let it be mine.
The aunt — who had Denise's cheekbones and none of Denise's shine — brought out two glasses of lemonade, set them down, and went back inside without performing anything for anyone. I was grateful to her for that in a way I couldn't have explained.
Before Brooke came out, the aunt stood a moment with her hand on the screen door. "She's carried that ribbon in her pocket since the second night she got here," she said. "Sleeps with it under her pillow." She stopped there, like she'd said more than she meant to. "Just so you know what it took her to bring it."
Brooke came out the screen door slowly, like the porch might object.
She looked smaller. That was the shock of it, and I stood there hating that it was a shock. No gown, no sash, no sprayed crown of hair — just a girl in jeans with her hair in a plain ponytail and her hands buried in her pockets, twelve years old and hollowed out around the eyes.
Five months of my life she had been a kind of weather. Now she was a person standing on a porch, and she was scared of me, and some tired part of me understood exactly how that felt.
"Hi," she said.
"Hi," I said.
Her hand came out of her pocket holding something she'd clearly been gripping the whole drive of her morning, and she held it out over the porch rail space between us. The ribbon.
Faded blue, wrinkled from being kept in a fist or the bottom of a drawer, one end gone slightly ragged. "This is yours," she said. "Mom gave it to me, but it was yours. I knew it was yours the whole time."
Then she tried to apologize, and the apology couldn't finish its sentence.
"I'm sorry," she said. "I knew it was — I mean, I should've — when you were in the — " Her voice went thinner and thinner looking for the end of it, and the end of it wasn't there, and she stopped, and looked at her shoes, and cried standing up without any drama in it at all, just tears arriving like she'd been out in rain.
I didn't finish the sentence for her. All those months I had finished everybody's sentences — yes ma'am, sorry, right away — and I stood on that porch and let the silence do whatever it was going to do, and it did something I didn't expect: it just sat there with us, two girls and a ribbon, neither of us rescued.
The lemonade glasses sweated on the porch rail, untouched, the whole time. At some point Brooke reached for hers, thought better of it, and put her hand back in her lap, and I recognized the gesture so completely it hurt: a girl checking a room before she was allowed to want something in it.
The memories stacked up anyway, the way they'd been doing. Brooke complaining the food was cold. The plate going off the edge of the table. Mom will say you hit me.
And underneath all of it, the night the cot was stripped — Brooke in the laundry-room doorway in the dark, holding a slice of bread she could not quite dare to hand over, before she turned and went back to bed.
Both of those were true at the same time, just like Dad said. I was getting tired of how true it was.
I took the ribbon. It was warm from her hand. "Thank you for bringing it back," I said — exactly that much, no more, because I didn't owe more and I wasn't going to rehearse more, and something in her face said she had expected less than that and it landed on her like the difference mattered.