When she had gone, Chloe straightened the cuffs of the blue coats, lining up the buttons as if she could get the rest of this conversation into order in the same fashion.
“He thought you didn't pay any attention to the plaques. He described you as a person who hires another person to think about engraving. Which I suppose a rich person might be. I don't know enough rich people.”
“Don't put your father to the trouble of hearing you say that.”
She studied my face. I thought she was deciding how much of what she had to say I was likely to be able to stand. Instead she was trying to decide if she could afford to believe that the kind of person Ethan described could take herself to a little room above a bowling alley and listen to the way another life sounded when nothing serious was wrong.
She handed me one of the coats to hold while she picked a crooked seam. There were needle marks on the pad of her left thumb. I thought of her at the house that first morning, how easy it would have been never to imagine her hands doing work.
“I gave Ethan the scan,” she said.
The building seemed unusually quiet. Downstairs somebody was oiling the lanes.
“He said he wanted a plaque made for your father's scholarship. I'd done the costume lettering. I took the sheet home, straightened it out and scanned it at the copy shop. Brought it back that afternoon. He said it was to be a surprise.”
“Which signature did he want?”
“The fourth. He sent me a picture of the part he wanted.”
She showed me the message. February the ninth. There was a heart at the end. It was a yellow heart, the one Ethan sent to professional acquaintances he had begun to think of as friends. I had not known until then that I knew the order in which he changed the colors of his hearts.
Chloe put the coat down. “If you need me to say I knew what he wanted it for, I didn't.”
“I need you to say what happened.”
“And if what happened makes me look stupid?”
“Welcome to the club,” I said. It was the first time since I met her that we had laughed at the same thing. She sent the whole conversation to Nathan, then finished unpicking the seam.
The Scholarship Girl
Kit was my father's last scholarship girl. We found her name on an application filled out in purple pencil and signed by a parent with a pen that had almost run dry. She wanted to build sets in which the moon would come up all by itself. The committee awarded her the exact sum of three hundred and seventeen dollars for pulleys, card stock, lumber and something she charmingly called celestial paint.
The program had been billed for twenty thousand.
Until then I had been able to keep two columns in my head. On the left was my marriage and on the right my company. Finding Kit in the money joined the two columns with a thick purple line.
There was another application behind hers. A teenage boy wanted to study chemical engineering on the strength of a summer spent cleaning costumes and wondering why the liquid used at the shop could remove a spot from silk without removing the color. He had written his essay in an elaborate hand, medium black ink replaced every two pages by different blues, as if the adults around him could not quite keep him in pens. He requested the cost of two evening classes at the community college and a bus pass. Somebody had marked his application approved with the orange pencil my father used to keep in a jar above the dispatch sink.
The money actually paid was the requested sum. The sum charged to his file later was much larger. I rang the college to ask whether he still attended. They quite properly declined to tell me anything beyond the cost of admission to the course. It astonished me that I had lived in a world where simply stating who I was had so often purchased access to the details of somebody else's life. The young woman at the desk explained the privacy rules in the voice you use to tell people visiting a nursery that they can't take a baby home even if the baby appears to like them.