Diane Carter had always been a woman who knew what she wanted, and what she wanted was control. She had grown up in a house like the one she lived in now, with a long dining table and good plates and candles, and she had married a man who had money, and she had raised two sons to believe that the family name mattered more than anything else, and she had never worked a day in her life, not because she could not, but because she did not have to, and she had never understood why other people had to work, why my mother had to work two jobs, why my mother wore a plain blue dress, why my mother did not have jewellery, or a car, or a house like hers, and she had decided, long ago, that people like my mother were servants, not guests, and that they should be treated as such, and she had treated my mother that way from the first time they met, at our engagement dinner, when she had looked at my mother's dress and said, in a voice loud enough for everyone to hear, that it was nice, for someone who worked in a shop, and I had laughed, because I did not know what else to do, and Ryan had laughed, and my mother had lowered her eyes, and I had told myself it was a joke, that Diane did not mean it, that she was just old-fashioned, and I had been telling myself that for three years.
The first year of our marriage, Diane had invited us to dinner every Sunday, and I had gone, because Ryan had asked me to go, and my mother had come sometimes, when Diane invited her, which was not often, and when she did come, Diane would seat her at the far end of the table, near the kitchen, and would serve her last, and would talk over her, and would ask her about her job, and then would look surprised when my mother said she worked in a shop, as if she had forgotten, as if she had never heard it before, and Ryan would sit beside his mother, and he would not say anything, and I would sit beside my mother, and I would not say anything, and afterwards, in the car, my mother would say it was fine, that Diane was just like that, that I should not worry, and I would believe her, because I wanted to believe her, because I did not want to admit that my husband's mother hated my mother, and that my husband was letting her do it.
The second year, it got worse. Diane started to invite us without my mother, and when I asked why, she said that the table was too small, or that my mother would be bored, or that she had already eaten, and Ryan said it was fine, that we could see my mother another time, and I did, I saw her another time, in her small kitchen, with a cup of tea, and she would ask me how dinner was, and I would say it was fine, and she would smile, and I would know she knew, and she would know I knew, and neither of us would say it, because saying it would make it real, and we were both too tired to make it real. Diane started to make jokes about my mother's hands, about the way they looked, about the way they were rough from work, and she started to make jokes about my mother's house, about the way it was small, about the way it needed painting, and she started to make jokes about my brother, about the way James talked too much, about the way James dressed, about the way James had not gone to the right school, and Ryan laughed, and Mark laughed, and Susan laughed, and I laughed, because I did not know what else to do, and my mother was not there to hear it, and I told myself that was better, that it was better she did not hear it, even though I knew it was worse, because it meant I was laughing at her when she was not there to defend herself.
The third year, the year that ended at that dinner table, Diane stopped pretending. She stopped inviting my mother at all, and when I asked her why, she said, in front of Ryan, that my mother was not family, that she was just my mother, and that family dinners were for family, and Ryan said nothing, and I said nothing, and I went to dinner alone, and I sat at the long table, and I ate steak, and I drank wine, and I listened to Diane talk about her friends, and her house, and her sons, and I thought about my mother, sitting alone in her kitchen, with a cup of tea, and I felt sick, and I did not know why, because I had felt sick for a long time, and I had learned to ignore it, to push it down, to tell myself it was nothing, that it was just stress, or tiredness, or the food, and it was not until that night, when Diane set the plate of bones in front of my mother, that I understood what the sickness was. It was shame. Not my mother's shame. My shame. For sitting at that table, for eating that steak, for letting Diane treat my mother like a servant, for letting Ryan watch it happen, for being the daughter who did not stand up, for being the wife who did not speak, for being the woman who lowered her eyes, just like her mother, and called it strength.