The street did not know whom to comfort, Paula realized. That was the trouble. Fair Oaks had a script for a house fire and a script for a death and a script for a new baby, but it had no script for the man next door being arrested at dawn for sabotaging the woman next door, and so it was improvising with carbohydrates.
The group chat was worse. "Fair Oaks Neighbors" had been, until that week, a sedate stream of lost-cat photos and recommendations for gutter cleaners. Now it scrolled faster than Paula could read: speculation, half-remembered sightings of Tom's truck, a theory from someone on the next street that it was about a property-line feud, a defense of Tom from a man who had worked with him at the warehouse, a counter from a woman who said nobody was defending anything until the facts were out.
Paula read for five minutes, felt her jaw begin to ache, and called Daniel at the school.
"Post one message," she said. "Factual. Then mute the chat."
"What should it say?"
She thought for a moment, choosing the words the way she chose exhibits: only what could be proven, nothing that could be argued with. "Our internet and phone lines were cut Monday night. The police are involved. We won't be commenting further. Thank you for understanding. Sign it from you."
Daniel was quiet for a beat. "You sure? People are going to fill the silence with whatever they want."
"They're already doing that," Paula said. "At least this way the silence has a frame around it."
He posted it. The chat went briefly, almost respectfully, quiet — and then resumed at a lower simmer, the way a pot does when you turn the burner down but not off. Paula muted it on her phone and did not unmute it for a month.
Individual texts still came through, and those she answered, briefly and the same way each time: Thank you for thinking of us. We're fine. The police are handling it. She did not say Tom's name in any of them. It felt important, suddenly, not to be the person who said it first in writing.
That evening, she saw Ruth take the shepherd's pie out to the trash, still covered in foil, untouched. Paula watched from behind her office curtain and felt something complicated move through her chest — not satisfaction, not pity exactly, but the recognition of a woman performing the motions of a normal life while the foundation tilted underneath her.
She let the curtain fall and went back to her exhibits. Mrs. Henderson, at the door with the lasagna, confessed what Paula had already guessed. "I didn't know whether to bring it here or there," she said, shifting the dish in her oven-mitted hands. "I stood in my kitchen for ten minutes, Paula. Ten minutes, holding a lasagna, like it was a moral decision."
"Here is fine," Paula said gently. "There is fine too. It's a lasagna, Helen. It doesn't have to pick a side."
Mrs. Henderson laughed, a startled sound, and some of the tension went out of her shoulders. "Your mother would have known what to do."
"My mother would have brought two," Paula said, and took the dish, and Mrs. Henderson went home lighter than she'd arrived.
When Daniel called that evening, Paula had him read the draft message aloud before posting.
"'Our internet and phone lines were cut Monday night,'" he read. "'The police are involved. We won't be commenting further. Thank you for understanding.'"
"Add 'please respect the Adlers' privacy too'?" Lucia suggested from the couch, not looking up from her phone.
Paula considered it. "No," she said finally. "That tells people there's something to respect, which tells them there's something to discuss. Keep it to us. Keep it to facts."
Daniel posted it. The chat exhaled, visibly, in the way of group chats — a few prayer-hand emojis, a "thanks for letting us know," and then, within the hour, the simmer resumed at a lower temperature. Paula muted it and felt the small, specific relief of a woman who has closed a door she didn't have to stand behind.
The arbitration resumed next week, and the panel would not care about casseroles.
Chapter 21: The Second Hearing Day
The hearing resumed on a Tuesday at nine in the morning, exactly one week after the first day, and Paula joined it from her home office with the lines repaired, the router humming, and both monitors glowing.
She had laid everything out the night before, the way she had before the first hearing: headset on the left, printed exhibits in order on the right, a glass of water where she couldn't knock it over, the hearing notice printed and taped to the edge of the desk where she could see it. Daniel had mounted nothing new yet — the backup connection was still a plan, not a device — but the fiber line was fresh and tested, and the utility box outside was closed and latched, and Paula had checked it herself that morning before Daniel could.